Has our Attorney-General confused Dan Duggan with Darcy Dugan?

Dan Duggan’s staunch supporters, their 4 yr weekly vigil outside US Consulate North Sydney

By Terry Dwyer

For younger Australians unfamiliar with the name, Darcy Dugan (1920–1991) was one of Australia’s most notorious career criminals and prison escape artists. Known as Houdini, he became infamous for armed robberies, bank hold-ups and a succession of extraordinary prison escapes. In 1950, he and an accomplice were sentenced to death following an armed bank robbery in which a bank manager was seriously wounded. Their sentences were subsequently commuted to life imprisonment.

Dugan spent much of his life behind bars, but his story was not entirely one-dimensional. After his release in 1967, he worked at Sydney’s Wayside Chapel, became involved in prison reform and gave evidence to the 1977–78 Royal Commission into New South Wales prisons, helping expose the brutal treatment of inmates. He died in 1991. His extraordinary life is documented in his autobiography, Bloodhouse, written with Michael Tatlow.

So why compare Darcy Dugan with Dan Duggan?

The similarity in their surnames provides an opportunity for a pointed question. Darcy Dugan was a convicted Australian bank robber whose criminal exploits made him a household name. Dan Duggan, by contrast, is an Australian citizen, husband, father and former military pilot who has spent more than four years in detention while facing extradition proceedings initiated at the request of the United States. He has not been convicted of the alleged offences. The question I want Australians to consider is whether the authorities have lost sight of the fundamental distinction between a convicted criminal and an Australian citizen and father of six, who is fighting allegations through an unfair extradition process.

An Australian citizen, a convicted terrorist and a disturbing double standard in our justice system.

On 29 October 2026, Federal Parliament heard renewed concerns about the impending release of convicted terrorist Isaac El Matari.

Liberal MP Andrew Wallace questioned why the Government had not sought to keep El Matari detained, describing him as a dangerous terrorist. Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke told Parliament that El Matari’s views and planning were “beyond contempt.”

The media have reported extensively on El Matari’s terrorism convictions, his plans for an Islamic State presence in Australia and the security concerns surrounding his release.

The Federal Court subsequently granted an interim control order sought by the Australian Federal Police, ahead of El Matari’s scheduled release on 1 November. The Government had not pursued a continuing detention order, which could potentially have extended his imprisonment by up to five years. Minister Burke explained that the legal threshold for such an order was extremely high.

Yet there is another aspect of this story that deserves public scrutiny.

AN AUSTRALIAN CITIZEN IN EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES

Since his arrest on 21 October 2022, Australian citizen Dan Duggan has spent more than four years in maximum-security detention awaiting extradition to the United States.

For the first 19 months, he was held in solitary confinement under an “Extreme High Risk Restricted” (EHRR) classification. He was shackled at the wrists and ankles and made to wear an orange jumpsuit reminiscent of those worn by Guantanamo Bay detainees. In my view, this treatment was designed to humiliate and break him.

Earlier this year, a stabbing incident was reported at Macquarie Correctional Centre. Then, on 2 August 2026, another inmate was seriously injured in a stabbing involving two homemade weapons. He suffered injuries to his head and neck and was airlifted to Westmead Hospital.

These incidents need to be considered alongside the findings of an official inspection by the NSW Inspector of Custodial Services, tabled in the NSW Parliament in December 2025.

The inspection recorded 33 inmate assaults at Macquarie during the 12 months from July 2023 to June 2024. More significantly, inspectors raised concerns about vulnerable remand prisoners being exposed to intimidation, threats and violence.

A WORD ABOUT THE PEOPLE WHO WORK INSIDE OUR PRISONS

I want to make something very clear. This article is not an attack on the ordinary prison officers, NSW Police or Federal Police.

Having visited Dan regularly, I have personally witnessed many prison officers treating him with kindness, consideration and humanity. They are good, decent people doing an extremely difficult job under challenging circumstances.

I have also witnessed other prisoners and visitors showing Dan genuine support and empathy.

The official inspection of Macquarie Correctional Centre itself recorded largely positive interactions between prison staff and inmates, acknowledging the professionalism of officers and the efforts they make to treat prisoners as human beings.

There is something particularly telling about the concern shown by police officers outside the prison system.

Every Thursday, supporters gather outside the United States Consulate in North Sydney to hold peaceful vigils calling for Dan’s release. On numerous occasions, NSW and Federal Police officers attending or passing the gatherings have asked supporters how Dan is holding up.

I have witnessed these exchanges myself.

These officers are also decent Australians. They are doing their jobs, but they are human beings who recognise when something does not seem right. They should not be blamed for the injustice that supporters believe has been inflicted on Dan by decisions made at the highest levels of government, particularly within the Attorney-General’s Department.

It is important to distinguish between the people carrying out their duties with professionalism and compassion and the political and departmental decision-makers responsible for the decisions affecting Dan’s future.

THE AFP’S FINDINGS: A QUESTION THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL CANNOT IGNORE

The Attorney-General’s Department has long been aware of a particularly significant fact: Australia’s own law enforcement agency identified no Australian offending by Dan and commenced no investigation into him.

Its records state:

“The AFP, who is the appropriate law enforcement agency with responsibility for investigation of the types of offences for which Mr Duggan is accused, has confirmed that it did not identify any Australian offending, nor commence any investigation into Mr Duggan.”

This raises a fundamental question about dual criminality, the requirement that the conduct underlying an extradition request must also constitute an offence under Australian law.

How can that requirement be reconciled with the AFP’s confirmation that it identified no Australian offending?

The AFP’s statement does not, by itself, settle the legal question of dual criminality. However, it raises an important question that the Attorney-General should answer.

Despite this finding, the Attorney-General’s Department continued to facilitate the US extradition proceedings.

It is difficult to understand how the Commonwealth can reconcile its obligation to protect Australian citizens with its decision to pursue the extradition of one of its own citizens when its own law enforcement agency found no Australian offending.

AN EXTRAORDINARY DOUBLE STANDARD

Now consider the contrast with the concerns being expressed by our politicians about El Matari.

One man was convicted of terrorism offences and served a substantial prison sentence. The other, Dan Duggan, has never been charged with or convicted of a criminal offence in Australia, not even a parking fine, endured more than four years of maximum-security detention awaiting extradition, both though have been housed at the same facility.

Our politicians are publicly expressing concern about the security implications of El Matari’s release. Yet where is that same level of public concern for Dan Duggan?

This is not about comparing the two men or suggesting any association between them. It is about the decisions, priorities and apparent double standards of the Australian authorities.

If the Government is so concerned about the security risks posed by convicted terrorists, why has it shown so little apparent concern for the treatment, welfare and rights of an Australian citizen who has not been charged or convicted of any offence?

HAS AUSTRALIAN CITIZENSHIP BECOME EXPENDABLE?

There is an even bigger question here concerning Australia’s sovereignty.

The Commonwealth has facilitated an extradition process on behalf of a foreign government, despite the AFP’s finding that it identified no Australian offending.

The Attorney-General’s Department has continued to pursue the US request, while Dan’s ability to defend himself has been severely constrained.

Dan has been denied Legal Aid on three occasions, according to his supporters, partly because he has not been charged under Australian law and therefore does not meet the relevant eligibility requirements. The very absence of Australian charges that distinguishes his case has become an obstacle to obtaining publicly funded legal assistance.

His family has also endured severe financial and emotional hardship, including the freezing of assets. His wife, Saffreine, and six Australian children have been deprived of their husband and father for more than four years.

There are also serious questions about the conduct of ASIO. The Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security reportedly found that ASIO had “transcended the bounds of propriety” in relation to Dan Duggan. The details remain contained in a classified report, leaving Dan and the Australian public with limited visibility of what occurred.

These circumstances inevitably raise questions about whether geopolitical considerations have influenced the handling of Dan’s case. Some have speculated that he has become an AUKUS bargaining chip. That remains speculation, but the Australian Government should do more to dispel such concerns.

WHO IS PAYING FOR THIS?

There is another aspect that Australian taxpayers should be asking about.

The Commonwealth has funded the US Government’s legal representation in Australia as part of the extradition proceedings, while the Attorney-General’s Department has acted in support of the US extradition request.

Think about that apparent imbalance: Australian public resources are being used to facilitate a foreign government’s extradition case against an Australian citizen, while that citizen struggles to secure financial assistance to defend himself.

There are, however, many prisoners housed at Macquarie who are serving sentences for very serious crimes and who do receive Legal Aid.

The financial cost is one thing. The damage to public confidence in Australia’s independence, judicial impartiality and sovereignty may prove far more lasting.

THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL MUST ANSWER

If this extradition proceeds, it raises serious questions about the protection Australian citizenship actually provides.

Could any Australian citizen find themselves detained for years at the request of a foreign government, without an Australian criminal charge or conviction, while being denied meaningful access to the resources needed to defend themselves?

What protection does citizenship offer if the Commonwealth places the interests of a foreign extradition request ahead of the welfare and rights of its own citizen?

And why has the Attorney-General not intervened to bring this extraordinary situation to an end?

Dan Duggan is not Isaac El Matari. He is an Australian husband, father of six and citizen who deserves the protection of Australian law.

The ordinary prison officers, police officers and other Australians who have shown Dan compassion should not have to carry the burden of decisions made by those in positions of political power.

They have demonstrated something that seems to have been missing from the Government’s handling of this case: basic humanity.

After more than four years, it is time for the Attorney-General to exercise her discretion and stop this extradition.

Has the Attorney-General confused Dan Duggan with Darcy Dugan?

Or has Australia simply forgotten what its citizenship is supposed to mean?

REFERENCES

  1. NSW Inspector of Custodial Services – Inspection of Macquarie and Hunter Correctional Centres 2024. Particularly relevant are the findings on inmate assaults, vulnerable remand prisoners and staff interactions.

  2. NSW Parliament – Tabled Papers, 17 December 2025. Official record of the inspection report being tabled.

  3. Daily Telegraph – 2 August 2026. Report of the stabbing at Macquarie Correctional Centre and the inmate being airlifted to Westmead Hospital.

  4. ABC News – 29 October 2026. Federal parliamentary coverage of Isaac El Matari, Andrew Wallace’s questions and Tony Burke’s response.

  5. The Australian – October 2026. Reporting on the AFP’s interim control order application and El Matari’s scheduled release.

  6. OpenAustralia – House of Representatives, 29 October 2026. Parliamentary exchange between Andrew Wallace and Tony Burke concerning El Matari.

See also: If the US can sanction international judges, could Australian judges be at risk?


Terry Dwyer
is a 5th Generation Australia-born citizen, his people came to Australia from Ireland in 1830 on the convict ship the Hercules, he is a retired Multi award winning Builder and award winning Artist.

Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN

Dear Reader,

Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.

Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.

Donate here:

PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below

Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969

Donate Button

We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.

Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.

With gratitude,

The AIMN Team

15 Comments

  1. Terry, your article raises a question that goes beyond the individual circumstances of Dan Duggan: how should a democratic state balance international security cooperation with its constitutional responsibilities towards its own citizens?

    Extradition is a legitimate instrument of international judicial cooperation, but it must never become a substitute for independent legal scrutiny, procedural fairness, or the protection of individual rights.

    One distinction is particularly important here: the absence of a domestic criminal charge does not, by itself, settle the legal question of extradition. However, neither should an extradition request from a powerful ally reduce the receiving state’s responsibility to examine the evidence, the applicable legal standards, and the conditions under which the individual is detained.

    The concerns raised about prison placement, prolonged isolation, access to legal representation, and the findings concerning ASIO deserve transparent and independent scrutiny. These are not merely administrative questions; they concern institutional accountability and public confidence in the rule of law.

    There is also a broader strategic lesson. International partnerships derive their credibility not only from intelligence-sharing and security cooperation, but from the confidence that each participating state retains the independence to apply its own laws and protect the rights of its citizens.

    A state’s sovereignty is tested not only by how it manages relations with powerful allies, but also by whether it preserves its legal independence when those relationships become difficult.

    The essential question is therefore not whether Australia should cooperate with the United States, but whether that cooperation remains fully consistent with Australia’s own legal principles and institutional responsibilities.

  2. Thank you for this article. I have been appalled and disgusted about Australia’s handling of this situation and the negligence of the usual suspects, the MSM, in reporting it. It shows (or should show) the rest of us that we are nothing to this government, our citizenship carries no respect and the greed of the legal system extorts the families trying to battle the system, alone.

  3. Well, we are the 51st State of the United States of Incontinence, and Governor Albanese and his untrustworthy deputy, Dickie Marles,are all the way with a criminal administration,ostensibly led by a madman.

  4. The Unfair Shitheap of Arrogance, led by Donny Dogshit-Drainbrain, is totally untrustwothy, murderous, bent, sick, evil, so why should we, lovely pure naive suckerpucker Australia, follow these bastards in anything political, financial, commercial, military, dietary, media? Let us be friedly to all, no more.




  5. Well said Jen, and thank you for the headsup.

    Based on the three allegations in the US indictment against Duggan related to training Chinese pilots in South Africa, he is not eligible for extradition. As an Australian citizen, he was not under US jurisdiction when he committed the alleged acts in the indictment, and

    the allegations do not satisfy the basic requirement of dual criminality as they are not crimes in Australia.

    When British pilots who worked alongside Duggan in South Africa faced similar allegations in 2022, the British government stated frankly they had broken no British law and had nothing to answer for.

    The Australian government were not as forthright as their British counterparts: in 2022, the Australian Federal Police arrested Duggan on behalf of the United States, and Attorney General Mark Dreyfus approved his extradition, by retrospectively applying a 2018 law which meant Duggan’s alleged actions in 2012 met the dual criminality requirement. (my emphasis)
    https://michaelwest.com.au/prioritising-war-mongering-ally-over-australian-citizen-dan-duggan-to-be-extradited/

    Craig Isherwood, National Secretary of the Australian Citizens Party – strong advocates for Duggan – told MWM, “To be extradited for a crime that a foreign country alleges you have committed, that alleged crime must also be a crime in Australia.”

    This is the normal principle applied in extradition cases. In addition, the crime should be legal in both countries involved at the time it was committed. In this case, the laws that would have made the alleged crimes unlawful in Australia were

    passed six years after Duggan allegedly did what he says he didn’t do.

    Duggan’s actions were not only legal in Australia at the time, but Australia’s Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA), licensed Dan Duggan to provide the exact training he did in 2012 in South Africa.

    According to Ishwerwood, “…to please Donald Trump, the Albanese government is handing over an Australian citizen who complied with all Australian laws, and they are applying a 2018 law retrospectively to do it.” (my emphasis)
    https://michaelwest.com.au/dan-duggans-extradition-fight-family-appeals-unjust-decision/

    The Albanese Government wants to render Australian citizen Dan Duggan to the corrupt authoritarian regime of Donald Trump. Michael Pascoe wonders at what point we officially surrendered our national self-respect.

    “It is clear that under this administration, federal authorities cannot be trusted to tell the truth,” the SMH’s Michael Koziol reported from Washington on Friday in an article detailing examples of those federal authorities repeatedly lying well before the slaughter of Renee Good in Minneapolis.

    He was stating the obvious or at least what was obvious to anyone who has been paying any sort of attention to the rapid decline of the United States, but it needs to be stated.

    The US Government is run by serial, obvious liars.

    In the case of the president, it’s reasonable to doubt if he even knows the difference between true and false anymore. In quick order, Trump, his Vice-President and his Secretary of Homeland Security all blatantly lied about Renee Good’s killing, defying everyone to believe their eyes given the copious video evidence.
    https://michaelwest.com.au/rendering-an-australian-citizen-to-the-corrupt-regime-of-donald-trump/

    It would seem that Labor had an Australian citizen arrested on a request from the USA, failed to undertake their responsibilities towards said Australian citizen by not investigating whether he’d broken Australian law, suppressed his family’s ability to raise funds to appeal his case, retrospectively applied laws to make what was a legal activity at the time turn into an illegal act. All of this at the request of a government that kills its own people and lies about it.

    The UK didn’t do that to its citizens, the British pilots, in similar circumstances.

    Isn’t one of the Australian government’s responsibilities to protect Australian citizens? Apparently, the UK government protected its citizens in this case.

    As Michael Pascoe asked, when did Australia officially surrender our national self-respect?

    Is there no end to Labor’s bad governance?

  6. Good stuff Jen and Thommo.

    I think it was Harry who said on another thread that we might as well become another state of the US.
    My reaction was to think that for all practical purposes we already are.
    But on reflection, that’s not the case.
    US states show more independence to Washington dictates than we do, so what does that make us?

  7. This article, highlighting as it does Dan Duggan’s predicament, yet again shines light on the arbitrary vindictiveness of the USA’s justice system and its willingness to pursue individuals whom it deems to have somehow or other acted in bad faith wrt to their relationship with that country.

    Given the innumerable examples that exist that demonstrate that country’s willingness to turn a blind eye towards real & actual criminal behaviour by individuals & corporations when it suits them, or when enough money has changed hands, or when the political affiliation of the offending parties is in sympathetic synchronicity with the powers that be… all of which have been employed in giving criminality a free pass… when contrasted with this particular case, or that of Julian Assange or any other person who is brave enough to call out the hypocrisy at play in American legal circles… often at great personal risk to themselves – recall that American politicians were calling for Assange to be executed – one is left with the impression that one is faced with and dealing with something akin to a criminal cabal, a Mafioso dressed in the robes of judges & lawyers with pistols packed beneath their cloth and all slavering for revenge against their deemed opponents.

    In a fair & just world, this once American now Australian citizen would be left alone to get on with his life and raise his family in peace in his adopted country. But no, America says no, lock him up and deliver him to us in shackles.

    A disgusting and abject surrender of sovereign process.

  8. Free Dan Duggan.
    Reject the US extradition request.
    With madmen such as Trump, Hegseth, ICE, etc running things in the US they cannot be trusted to dispense justice.

  9. Strange that USA wants to make a show trial of an Australian citizen who committed no crime either in US or Australian jurisdiction. If USA is so concerned about “terrorists” then Trump should have seized war criminal Netanyahu when he was last in New York for extradition to the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague, Netherlands.

  10. @ Bruce White: Agreed & well said. Thank you.

    I agree with the sentiments above, especially Thommo’s detailed historical report.

    Perhaps the question that needs to be answered is, ”Which US CIA agent under the Canberra Bubble demanded this inhumane and un-Australian victimisation of an Australian citizen”??

  11. Kanga has referred to this as a disgusting and abject surrender of sovereign process.
    Keep that thought in mind.

    A couple of weeks ago I mentioned that “almost every European leader is fit for restraint under medical supervision.”

    A “constitutional coup” is taking place in Poland right now, with Prime Minister Donald Tusk attempting to take control of Poland’s Constitutional Court while the Polish President was absent from the country on official business.

    The stupidity of Europe becoming an active participant in the Ukraine debacle is becoming more apparent by the day.

    Europe has suffered a severe economic decline by cutting itself off from Russia.
    Economic decline has caused dissenters across Europe to torch the place.
    And now we see Poland, that has been most vociferous in supporting the corrupt anti-democracy regime in Kiev, trying to keep control by taking over the judiciary.

    It won’t be long and we’ll be seeing them carted away in strait-jackets.

    Democracy is dying before our eyes.

    This is what happens when you surrender your sovereignty to the US.

    Once you surrender sovereignty on “minor” matters such as the one discussed here, you set the pattern.
    You normalise subservience.

    When the US confrontation with China turns into a “hot” war, guess where the line of contact will be.
    It ain’t gunna be Miami or San Diego.

  12. In regard to the problems in Poland as we speak, Polish MEP Dominik Tarczyński is explaining what is happening right now at Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal, calling it nothing less than a COUP D’ÉTAT!

    “In Poland, we have a liberal-left government led by Donald Tusk, who is the Prime Minister. What is happening right now with the Constitutional Tribunal is that they want to take it over and fill it with their own people.

    Why? Because they want to get rid of the Polish currency, bring us into the eurozone, and eliminate our secure borders. They are being pushed by the Germans, who want to spread the burden of illegal migration and send migrants to Poland.

    First of all, the Polish złoty is our constitutionally protected currency. They have to change the Constitution to replace it, and without the Constitutional Tribunal, they cannot do that.

    So, number one, they want to get rid of our currency and force us to adopt the euro and join the eurozone. Then they want to take our gold reserves, the largest in the European Union, to Frankfurt, to the European Central Bank, which is a German-based institution.

    They also want to open our borders. And they want to make sure that when they lose the next elections, which are coming next year, the Constitutional Tribunal will be unable to do anything to stop their actions or reverse what they have done.

    There are many more reasons, but I want you to understand one thing: they are under German influence. They are globalists, and we are fighting not just for Poland, but for Europe.

    Be like Poland. Be strong. Our nation is strong, and we are going to win this fight!”

    The EU is tearing itself apart.

  13. A-G Rowland sent me a letter in response telling me there was ‘nothing they could do’ to stop Duggan’s extradition, which is a disgustingly bald-faced lie on multiple counts. I wrote back ‘Exactly. You could do nothing. Yet you chose to do something.’ They unelicited made the decision to aid and abet the US government, when they didn’t have to. That was a CHOICE. A deliberate one. Last time I checked that qualifies as ‘doing something.’

  14. Well said Trey Tohrr.

    I’ve no time for Rowland’s blathering.

    She is a continuation of a long series of variously compromised Oz A-Gs. All persisting with undue secrecy, concealing the truth of Oz’s dubious and sometimes out-and-out illegal activities both here and in foreign jurisdictions, AND likewise concealing similar adventures by foreign states here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*