Chapter 16: First Nations in Canada and New Zealand – Shared Struggles, Shared Survival
Settler Colonies of the British Empire
Australia was not unique. Canada and New Zealand were also settler colonies of the British Empire, founded on the same logic: seize land, impose Crown sovereignty, and reshape Indigenous peoples into subjects of empire.
Each country has its own history, but the patterns are strikingly familiar:
Legal fictions that denied or diminished Indigenous sovereignty.
- Mass dispossession of land.
- Violence, disease, and forced removals.
- Suppression of language and culture.
- Systems of segregation and assimilation.
By comparing these nations, we see that Australia’s story is part of a much wider system of colonisation.
Canada: Residential Schools and Cultural Genocide
In Canada, the most infamous instrument of assimilation was the residential school system.
Beginning in the 1880s, Indigenous children were forcibly removed from families and placed in church-run schools, often hundreds of kilometres from home.
The motto of the system was explicit: “Kill the Indian in the child.”
Children were forbidden to speak their languages or practice their cultures.
Many endured horrific abuse – physical, sexual, and psychological.
Thousands died from neglect, disease, or mistreatment; many were buried in unmarked graves.
In 2015, Canada’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission concluded that the system amounted to cultural genocide.
Beyond schools, Canada also imposed reserves (paralleling Australia’s missions) and used pass systems to control Indigenous movement.
New Zealand: The Treaty of Waitangi and Its Limits
New Zealand’s colonisation followed a slightly different path, centred on the Treaty of Waitangi (1840).
Māori chiefs signed the treaty with the British Crown, intended to guarantee Māori rights while allowing British settlement.
However, the English and Māori versions of the treaty differed. The English version claimed sovereignty; the Māori version promised governance alongside protection.
Within decades, the Crown used the treaty as justification for massive land confiscations.
The New Zealand Wars (1845–1872) saw violent conflict as Māori defended their land against British forces.
Unlike in Australia, the treaty gave Māori a recognised place in law – but in practice, breaches were constant and devastating.
In the 20th century, the Waitangi Tribunal was established to investigate claims and breaches, leading to land settlements, reparations, and formal apologies.
Shared Patterns Across Nations
Despite differences in detail, the colonial strategies in Australia, Canada, and New Zealand reveal common threads:
Denial of sovereignty: Whether through terra nullius (Australia), the treaty’s reinterpretation (NZ), or unilateral Crown declarations (Canada).
Land theft: Indigenous peoples driven off or forced into reserves.
Child removal: Stolen Generations in Australia, residential schools in Canada, and assimilation schools in NZ.
Cultural suppression: Languages banned, ceremonies outlawed, identities ridiculed.
Racial hierarchy: Legal and social systems positioning Indigenous peoples as inferior.
Differences That Matter
New Zealand: Māori retained a stronger political presence, including representation in Parliament, and the Treaty of Waitangi remains a living legal document.
Canada: The Truth and Reconciliation process has been more formalised, with widespread recognition of harms.
Australia: Without a treaty, and with terra nullius only overturned in 1992 (Mabo), Australia lags behind in formal recognition and reparations.
These differences explain why truth-telling, treaty, and reconciliation remain such urgent tasks in Australia.
Survival and Resilience
Despite centuries of attempted erasure, First Nations in all three countries have survived.
Māori renaissance: Language revival, cultural resurgence, and political activism have made te reo Māori an official language and reshaped New Zealand identity.
First Nations in Canada: Idle No More and other movements have pushed Indigenous rights into the national spotlight.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples: Despite immense trauma, culture, song, dance, and law continue, with powerful movements for recognition and justice.
Survival is resistance. Shared struggles across continents show that Indigenous peoples have endured colonisation not through submission, but through resilience.
Why These Comparisons Matter
Looking at Canada and New Zealand reveals two truths for Australians:
- Colonisation was not unique here – it was a global system with similar strategies.
-
Other countries have begun truth-telling and reparations processes in ways Australia has resisted.
The lesson is clear: Australia cannot continue to hide behind myths of exceptionalism. It must face the truth, just as its settler-colonial cousins have begun to do.
Where This Leads
Having explored global comparisons – Jim Crow, apartheid, Canada, and New Zealand – we now return home. The next section will address the ongoing legacies of colonisation in Australia: incarceration, child removals, health and education inequality, and the myth that “it’s all in the past.”
Continued tomorrow…
Link to Part 15:
From Ignorance to Understanding: Facing the Truth of Colonisation (Part 15)
Link to Part 17:
From Ignorance to Understanding: Facing the Truth of Colonisation (Part 17)
Dear reader, we need your support
Independent sites such as The AIMN provide a platform for public interest journalists. From its humble beginning in January 2013, The AIMN has grown into one of the most trusted and popular independent media organisations.
One of the reasons we have succeeded has been due to the support we receive from our readers through their financial contributions.
With increasing costs to maintain The AIMN, we need this continued support.
Your donation – large or small – to help with the running costs of this site will be greatly appreciated.
You can donate through PayPal or credit card via the button below, or donate via bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
Be the first to comment