
A nation… is a group of persons united by a common error about their ancestry and a common dislike of their neighbours. (Karl Deutsch, Nationality and its alternatives, 1969, as quoted by Shlomo Sand’s introduction to ‘The invention of the Jewish People’ 2009).
Recent articles which have crossed my path regarding where the military support for Israel comes from indicated that the bulk of weaponry comes from the United States and various European nations, yet in each of these nations there is vocal opposition to the genocidal wars being conducted both in Gaza and in The West Bank. Opposition has also been expressed to the cross border incursions into Lebanon and by Israel.
Apart from the US, most of those other nations have signed onto the support for a two state solution in Palestine/Israel, and yet continue to supply military and political support which is making the concept of a two state solution near impossible despite the UN agreements.
I wonder why?
History points to several answers; some of that history dating back two thousand years, other answers more recent.
And one answer is profoundly religious.
Another is absolutely racist.
An interesting starting point is Biblical, the origin of the Abrahamic faiths, the origin of who are ‘god’s people’. In Genesis 15, the raging, childless Abram, before his name is changed to Abraham, is promised, in a vision “Do not be afraid, Abram, I am your shield, your very great reward”, (Verse 1) and the chapter concludes with:
‘… To your descendants I give you this land, from the Wadi of Egypt to the great river, the Euphrates – the land of the Kenites, Kenizzites, Kadmonites, Hittites, Perizzites, Rephaites, Amorites, Cannanites, Girgashites and Jesubites.’ (Verses 18 -21).
Abraham’s wife although some years younger than him, offered her slave, Hagar to Abraham, since Sarah was past child-bearing age, and from that union, a son was born, Ishmael.
The promise, through an angel to Hagar was that
“You are now pregnant and you will give birth to a son. You shall name him Ishmael, for the Lord has heard of your misery. He will be a donkey of a man, his hand will be against everyone and everyone’s hand against him, and he will live in hostility toward all his brothers.” (Genesis 16, Verses11, 12).
A few years later, miraculously, Abraham and Sarah had a son, Isaac, the father of the Old Testament people of Israel, but Abraham had a promise from God…
“And as for Ishmael, I have heard you: I will surely bless him; I will make him fruitful and will greatly increase his numbers. He will be a father of twelve rulers, and I will make him a great nation.” (Genesis 17, verse 20).
So for which son was the promise of the land from the Wadi of Egypt to the Euphrates River? Could it have been for both?
The seeds for generations of hatred were laid in the opening book of the Bible, a book held sacred by all three Abrahamic religions.
We fast forward to the Roman Empire at the time ascribed to the life of Jesus and the beginnings of the Christian faith, where in the city of Jerusalem, rebellion against the rule of Imperial Rome saw the destruction of the Second Temple in 70CE and the expulsion of the Jewish religious leaders, the diaspora, sending the priests and rabbis to distant corners of the empire and beyond.
An important question is who was actually expelled by the Romans, a question not raised in mythologising the expulsion, as cited in the Declaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel in 1948…
”After being forcefully exiled from their land, the people kept faith with it throughout their Dispersion, and never ceased to pray and hope for their return to it and for the restoration in it of their political freedom” (Shlomo Sand: The Invention of the Jewish People 2009, Page 129).
That myth is questioned by Sand where he explains clearly that the Jewish people were needed. Occupied Israel was an agricultural land, a land of farmers and herders of livestock…
“It did not pay to uproot the people of the land, the cultivators of produce, the taxpayers… They (The Romans) executed fighters, took captives and sold them into slavery, sometimes exiled kings and princes. But they definitely did not deport whole populations in the countries they conquered…” (Ibid, Page 130).
Rome needed the labour and produce of the population to support and feed the occupying administration and military.
And so, in the dispersal of the Jewish elites, the priests, rabbis and administrators of Roman Judea, the Jewish religion was also dispersed and through proselytising and conversion, a disparate people identified, through their faith, as Jewish.
Moving on several hundred years, we see the fall of the Roman Empire, especially that in the east, where Jews had established sizeable populations among the Khazars, a semi-nomadic people who had settled on the western end of the trading route, the Silk Road, where they traded in silks and spices and provided from the bounty of the land to feed the traders and travellers who passed through.
As described in Ghost Empire:
”… the Khazarian empire incorporated people from different races and religious traditions, welcoming Christians, Jews, Muslims and worshippers of the Mogol sky-god Tengri. Sometime in the ninth century, Tha Khazar nobility decided to convert to Judaism, which is astonishing, because unlike Muslims and Christians, Jews have rarely sought to convert other peoples. The Khazar legend of conversion tells of Bulan, the Khagan of the Khazars, who summoned sages from the the three great faiths to come to him to debate which was the best religion. The three sages argued for two days, and on the third day, the Khagan turned to the Christian priest.
‘What do you think priest?’ He asked. ‘Which of the other two religions do you prefer?’
‘My Lord,’ he replied. ‘the religion of the Israelites is better than that of the Muslims.’
Then the Khagan of the Khazars turned to the Muslim imam and asked, ‘Which do you prefer, the religion of the Jews or the Christians?’
“The religion of the Isrealites is preferable,’ he replied.
‘Well,’ said the Khagan, ‘you have both admitted with your own mouths that the religion of the Jews is better. Therefore I choose the religion of Israel.’ (Richard Fidler; Ghost Empire, 2016, Page 205).
With the passage of time, the people of Khazan were absorbed into the Ottoman and later the Russian Empires, and spreading through Eastern Europe where they remained essentially marginalised communities holding firmly to their religious practices, and because of the Christian influences, which included the clerical functions of recording births, marriages and deaths, assumed by the churches, both Catholic and Orthodox, their legal existence was not recorded, placing them outside the ability to purchase and own land, and so became in effect stateless, but being literate through the disciplines of their faith, were able to contribute to the economic and legal elements of the communities they were parts of.
Being part of, yet seperate from those communities, made them convenient scapegoats at times of difficulty, as so well described in the play and movie, Fiddler on the Roof.
Other historical events targeted Jews, events such as The Spanish Inquisition, which although not specifically aimed at Jews, sought to rid the Catholic world of what were deemed to be heretical practices, but again, when circumstances determined a scapegoat was needed to redress some problem or other, the marginalised were a ready target, the Jews filled the need.
The administrative and financial competencies of having a literate sector in a community, saw Jews in important positions, but under the control of the church, through the Inquisition, there was a need for people to be baptised, and many Jews nominally converted, but were suspected to retain their ‘heretical’ religious practices, such as the Shabbat, the Friday meal which marked the beginning of the sabbath, the Jewish day of rest.
Under the Inquisition, Jews were expelled from Spain and those who remained, but were thought to privately practice their faith, to partake of the rituals were punished through torture and execution, between 3,000 and 4,000 were burned at the stake.
Pogroms against Jews were common throughout Europe.
The Canterbury Tales includes ‘The Prioress’s Tale, which opens with:
“In Asia once there was a Christian town
In which, long since, a Ghetto used to be
Where there were Jews, supported by the Crown
For the foul lucre of their usury,
Hateful to Christ and all his company.
And through this Ghetto one might walk or ride
For it was free and open, either side.
(The Canterbury Tales Book Club Edition, 1986, Page 110).
The tale goes on to tell of a young boy murdered by the Jews and restored to life by the power of the Virgin.

In England, the Pogroms of 1189 and 1190 saw the population of Jews in London, York and other cities and towns almost completely eliminated, driven by the religious fervour of the Crusades, but some local noblemen saw the pogroms as an opportunity to erase the large amounts of debt they owed to Jewish moneylenders.
Pogroms in the Russian Empire during the nineteenth and into the twentieth century, and the rise of European Nationalism saw many Jews seek solace in other countries, particularly in ‘the new world’, the US and other colonised countries, but while many settled, the discrimination did not end, in large measure because many remained very visible, both in establishing Ghettos and retaining their religious dress codes.
Increasingly, as the doors of immigration became harder and harder to open, the rise of Zionism sought a safe place for Jews to call their homeland, and as an appeasement, the Balfour Declaration of 1917 opened the way to the establishment of Israel in the British Protectorate of Palestine.
So why is there support for Israel’s genocidal war, mainly from European people, including in post colonial countries such as USA and Australia? Why are those countries willing to support a military endeavour which is almost a mirror image of the violence carried out against the Jewish people throughout the last 2,000 years.
When we read the history of the people who define as Jewish, a couple of threads occur.
The first is one of race.
Tracing back the European Jews to the ninth century, the Jews, particularly of Eastern Europe are not originally of Jewish heritage, of Jewish bloodlines, but through an act of a Khazari leader, became Jewish through his adoption of Judaism as a national religion. The Khazari people were not Middle Eastern, did not carry the bloodline of Abraham. But nor were they European.
And according to the quotes from Genesis, the Arab world is probably the closest to having Abrahamic bloodlines… probably through Ishmael rather than Isaac.
In a sense, they are between being an Arab people and a European people. I know that is not really a legitimate argument, it borders on the fake science of Eugenics, but racism is alive and well, and as pointed out in the opening quotation, deeply embedded in the sense of national identity. Think for a moment about the tropes being used to define what it is to be Australian. It is hardly ‘we love meat pies, kangaroos and Holden cars’ any more. Diets have changed and Holden cars are history, except for the badge engineering applied to some imports. We still do have kangaroos.
The scourge or religion has dominated the definitions of people through the history of the Jewish people. The belief that the promises of the Old Testament, that which reconciled sinful believers with God through the sacrifice of Christ, as told in the New Testament, and the belief that Christ was not the promised redeemer, but that person is still to come sometime, to save the children of Abraham from their hellish fate, a division which remains unresolved, and after 2,000 or so years, probably won’t be resolved anytime soon.
Add to that the other child of Abraham and the rise of Islam, and the divisions deepen.
Or could it be that there is a sense of guilt. A sense that the Christian European culture has so marginalised Jews for centuries, that there is a time for redress of some sort or another, and to finally grant Jews a safe place, a national state, and one which can fit into the mythological promises of Genesis granting Abraham’s descendants the land from the Wadi of Egypt to the Euphrates River becomes a make-good action, no matter how many Arabs, or descendants of that ‘donkey of a man’ suffer in fulfilling that promise.
Ah, the descendants of that ‘donkey of a man’, what an interesting description, how dehumanising, and printed in clear type in what is considered the holiest of holy books by some. Almost an excuse to allow for their eradication….
Or could they be descendants of those ten peoples named in Genesis 15, the ……ites, are then from either a Jewish or Christian perspective, disposable, with who ever said those words in promise for Abraham’s inheritance.
Oh, and aren’t they the same people whose lands were carved up at the fall of the Ottoman Empire, and have been raped of their wealth by those same supporters of Israel? People whose lands have been ravaged by war after war since the ‘peace to end all peace’ of the fall of the Ottoman Empire.
A guilt felt for the harm done over centuries to Jews the repeated charge of anti semitism when the call out is for the politics of Zionism, but allowing that same continued marginalisation of those ‘others’, who are not, according to an interpretation of the cited texts, of god’s people.
Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN
Dear Reader,
Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.
Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.
Donate here:
PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below
Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.
Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.
With gratitude,
The AIMN Team

@ Bert Hetebry: Another interesting article identifying the origin of the Greater Isrevil pipedream of Isrevil between the Nile and Euphrates Rivers.
The post 1945 support of the Jewish dream came from US President Eisenhower as a reaction to the Holocaust.
However, the English, ever locked into their self-serving belief that they owned and ran everything at that time, objected and suppressed Jewish nationalism in Jerusalem, until the arrival of shiploads of European Jewish refugees, fresh from a war of survival and unwilling to take ”No” for an answer. The 1948 Nakba resulted, the persecution of Indigenous Palestinians escalated and back in Washington the Jewish infiltration of the US State & Defence Departments began, and continues to this day.
The rise of the Viennese Jewish imperialist theology of Zionism in 1891 focussed thought on achieving ”Greater Isrevil”. This became perverted into ZION@ZISM by later religious rabbis wanting to avoid military service for Isrevil, and remains the underlying philosophy of the ZION@ZI Knesset, the amoral ZION@ZI IDF led by Butcher Bibi, trying to avoid Court appearances for alleged political corruption.
The depth of ZION@ZI penetration of US government is described in Maisel & Forman (2000) and has increased during the intervening 25+ year period.
It is this internal support within the US government that has influenced US government decisions always in favour of Isrevil and provided the US NE Military Industrial Complex with a wonderful bottomless pit market supplying armaments.
A short but necessarily incomplete analysis that I invite other to edit and add to so that we better understand why western governments have allowed the GAZA HOLOCAUST by Isrevil to occur.
L Sandy Maisel & Ira N Forman (2000) Jews in American Politics, Rowman& Littlefield Publishing Group, Maryland, pb, 350pp, ISBN 1-800-462-6420
The post 1945 support of the Jewish dream came from US President Eisenhower as a reaction to the Holocaust.
NEC:
Partly, but there was also a wide thread of antisemitism in it. Rather send them to the Middle East than have them at home. NIMBY works with bigotry as well.
“….yet in each of these nations there is vocal opposition to the genocidal wars …”
Cleverly crafted words of protest are futile in these nations. Politicians are not affected by words. Western governments do not react to “stern letters”. What is required is active physical protest that disrupts the material and financial flow of those directly involved with this blight on humanity.
Agreed, why indeed.
Racism and bigotry go hand in hand.
Meanwhile, back in the GAZA GENOCIDE conducted by the amoral ZION@ZI IDF on behalf of the ZION@ZI Isrevil Knesset led by Butcher Bibi, the death toll of children has been recognised with the ”Wall of Tears” naming the 18,457 kids assassinated by bombardment to displace & dispossess the Indigenous Palestinian landowners for the benefit of a TACO Trumpery international re-building programme to house disgruntled ZION@ZI sympathisers from America, Europe and indeed the world.
From P&I 151026:
https://pearlsandirritations.com/post/2026/10/wall-of-tears-18457-names-for-the-children-killed-in-gaza/