
The Liberals and Pauline Hanson: Allies Against Labor, Enemies on the Right?
The Liberal Party and One Nation may share a desire to remove Labor from office, but when two parties compete for the same voters, cooperation can quickly become a contest for survival.
There is an old saying in politics that there are no permanent friends, only permanent interests. It is a useful starting point for examining the increasingly complicated relationship between the Liberal Party and Pauline Hanson’s One Nation.
Both parties want to be the alternative to Labor. Both are campaigning on issues including immigration, energy policy and the cost of living.
Yet there is one rather inconvenient problem.
They are fishing in much the same electoral pond, and neither appears particularly keen to let the other have the best spot.
The question is not whether the Liberals and One Nation can cooperate. Clearly, they can. The more interesting question is whether they can cooperate without undermining each other’s political ambitions.
Recent events suggest that this will be a difficult balancing act.
Farrer: Friends when it suits them
The 2026 Farrer by-election provided an illuminating example of how the relationship works.
The Liberal Party had held the electorate before the by-election, but its candidate, Raissa Butkowski, received just 12.4 per cent of first-preference votes. One Nation’s David Farley won 39.5 per cent and ultimately defeated independent Michelle Milthorpe, receiving 57.6 per cent of the final two-candidate-preferred vote.
The Liberals and Nationals recommended preferences for One Nation ahead of the independent. At first glance, this might suggest a degree of cooperation between the parties.
However, election analyst Antony Green’s subsequent examination of the preference flows revealed a more nuanced picture. Liberal preferences flowed to One Nation at a rate of 59 per cent, compared with 69.1 per cent for Nationals preferences. Furthermore, One Nation would have won the contest without Liberal preferences, although the preference flows contributed to the final margin.
These figures are worth examining because they demonstrate that the Coalition’s two constituent parties do not necessarily have identical relationships with One Nation. They also remind us that a party’s recommendation does not guarantee that its voters will follow it.
Farrer was a by-election, not a federal contest between Labor and a conservative opponent. Its results should not be treated as a template for the next general election.
Nevertheless, it demonstrates an important principle: preferences can be a tactical arrangement rather than an expression of political friendship.
The Liberals may be prepared to help One Nation defeat an independent in one electorate while having no intention of helping Hanson establish a stronger position against the Liberal Party nationally.
There is a difference between helping a potential ally win a battle and handing that ally the keys to the castle.
Angus Taylor draws a line
Liberal leader Angus Taylor appears to understand the distinction.
In June 2026, he ruled out an arrangement under which the Coalition and One Nation would divide up electorates between them, following suggestions from Liberal MP Tony Pasin that the parties might coordinate their efforts in seats where one had a better chance of defeating Labor.
In July, Taylor went further, categorically ruling out a Coalition with One Nation.
Speaking to the ABC’s 7.30, he said there was no plan to form any kind of coalition with Hanson’s party. He also warned that a One Nation government would leave Australia with what he described as “an eternity of pain.”
Taylor’s position is understandable from the perspective of a party seeking to form government. The Liberals want to attract voters away from Labor and retain their position as the principal alternative government. An arrangement that allowed One Nation to contest seats without Liberal opposition could undermine that objective.
But refusing to share electorates presents its own difficulties.
If One Nation continues to attract voters who previously supported the Coalition, the Liberals must compete against it. They cannot simply assume that those voters will return when the next federal election arrives.
Nor can they assume that voters who prefer One Nation on particular issues will necessarily accept the Liberal Party’s argument that it remains their natural political home.
The challenge for Taylor is to persuade voters that the Liberals can address their concerns without surrendering the party’s independence to a competitor.
That is a considerably more complicated task than simply telling One Nation to stay out of the Coalition’s way.
Hanson has other ideas
Pauline Hanson, meanwhile, has been making it clear that she does not intend to spend her political life as an appendage of the Liberal Party.
On 10 October, speaking at the Conservative Political Action Conference in Brisbane, Hanson urged conservative voters to abandon the Coalition. She criticised the Liberals for their previous commitments to climate targets and for creating the office of the eSafety Commissioner.
Her argument was straightforward: why should voters trust the Liberals to reverse policies that the Liberals themselves helped introduce?
Yet Hanson also indicated that One Nation would be prepared to work with the Coalition if doing so helped remove Labor from government.
There is a distinction here worth recognising.
Hanson is not necessarily rejecting cooperation with the Liberals. She is rejecting the assumption that cooperation requires One Nation to accept Liberal leadership or abandon its own political identity.
She wants conservative voters to consider One Nation as an alternative to the established parties, while retaining the option of negotiating with the Coalition when their interests coincide.
In effect, she is saying that the Liberals may be useful partners in removing Labor, but that does not mean they deserve the loyalty of voters who have become disillusioned with them.
This places Taylor in an awkward position.
If he dismisses One Nation, he risks appearing unwilling to acknowledge the concerns of voters who have moved towards Hanson. If he accommodates her too readily, he risks reinforcing the impression that One Nation is setting the agenda while the Liberals struggle to respond.
Neither option is particularly comfortable.
The battle for the conservative vote
The underlying problem is that the Liberals and One Nation are not simply competing over individual policies. They are competing over who gets to define conservatism in Australia.
For decades, the Liberal Party has presented itself as the principal alternative to Labor, bringing together business interests, socially conservative voters, regional communities and people who favour smaller government.
One Nation has built its appeal by challenging the established parties and campaigning against policies and institutions that Hanson argues have failed ordinary Australians.
There is considerable overlap between their positions on immigration, energy policy and aspects of social policy. But there are also differences in their political approaches, their constituencies and their ambitions.
The Liberals have to construct a credible alternative government. That requires them to demonstrate how their proposals would work across the economy, public services and the institutions of government.
One Nation can present itself as the party willing to challenge arrangements that the established parties have accepted. That message can appeal to voters who believe the political system has become unresponsive to their concerns.
The danger for the Liberals is that adopting more of One Nation’s positions may reinforce the perception that Hanson is setting the terms of the debate. Refusing to adopt them may leave the Liberals vulnerable to further defections of support.
This is not an argument that one party’s policies are necessarily better than the other’s. It is a description of the strategic problem confronting two parties competing for many of the same voters.
And it raises a question that neither party can easily avoid: if One Nation continues to grow, at what point does the Liberal Party cease to be the undisputed centre of conservative politics?
The electoral mathematics
The next federal election will provide another test of the relationship, although its outcome cannot be determined in advance.
Australia’s preferential voting system allows voters to rank candidates in the order they prefer. This creates opportunities for parties to recommend preferences to one another without forming a formal alliance.
But preferences are not a substitute for votes.
If the Liberals and One Nation both contest an electorate, they may divide voters who would otherwise support a single conservative candidate. Whether that benefits Labor, an independent or another candidate will depend on the primary votes, the candidates standing and the preferences that actually flow.
The Farrer result illustrates why these distinctions matter. One Nation’s substantial first-preference vote was central to its victory; the Liberal preference flow was not necessary for Farley to reach a majority in the final preference-flow calculation.
It would be a mistake to assume that the same circumstances will apply in other electorates, particularly those in which Labor is a major contender.
The political problem for the Liberals is therefore twofold.
They must compete with One Nation for first-preference votes while also considering how preferences might affect the final result. They must defend their own electoral territory without assuming that every voter who leaves the Coalition will eventually return.
For One Nation, the challenge is different but equally important. It must turn support for its message into durable electoral representation while deciding how much cooperation with the Coalition serves its own objectives.
A party that grows by attacking the established parties cannot easily abandon that message when it needs their assistance.
And a party that wants to remain the principal alternative government cannot comfortably watch a competitor claim an increasing share of its traditional support.
Can they work together without working against each other?
There is an obvious argument for cooperation between the Liberals and One Nation: both parties may benefit from defeating Labor in particular electorates or from supporting common legislative objectives.
But cooperation on individual issues does not resolve their underlying competition.
Taylor has ruled out a formal coalition and an arrangement to divide electorates. Hanson, for her part, has called on conservative voters to abandon the Coalition while remaining open to working with it to remove Labor from office.
Their public positions therefore leave room for tactical cooperation, but not a settled agreement about how the conservative side of Australian politics should be organised.
The distinction matters because both parties have something to lose.
The Liberals risk losing voters and seats to a party that challenges their claim to lead the right. One Nation risks limiting its own growth if it becomes too closely associated with the very political establishment it criticises.
They may share an opponent, but they do not necessarily share a destination.
And that is where the relationship becomes especially interesting. The closer the two parties become on policy, the more difficult it may be for voters to understand why they should choose one rather than the other. The further apart they move, the harder it may become to coordinate their efforts against Labor.
There is no simple solution to that dilemma.
The obstacle Hanson cannot ignore
In an earlier article, “Why Pauline Hanson will never be Australia’s prime minister,” I examined why Pauline Hanson becoming Australia’s prime minister faces formidable obstacles. The Liberal Party is one of them, not simply because it occupies much of the same political territory, but because it has its own reasons for resisting One Nation’s expansion.
The Liberals do not need to regard Hanson as an enemy on every issue. Nor does Hanson need to regard the Liberals as an enemy in every electorate.
But both parties have ambitions that cannot always be reconciled.
The Liberals want to retain their position as a party capable of forming government. Hanson wants One Nation to be recognised as a political force in its own right, not merely a source of preferences for another party.
Those ambitions can coexist for a time. They can even produce arrangements that benefit both parties.
Eventually, however, electoral competition demands that each party convince voters that it deserves their support more than its rival does.
That is the central tension in the relationship between the Liberals and One Nation. They can recommend preferences for one another, agree on selected policies and work towards removing Labor from office. None of that guarantees that they will agree on who should lead the alternative government, which policies should take priority or which party should represent conservative Australians.
Perhaps the most revealing question is not whether the Liberals and One Nation can be friends.
It is whether either party can afford to let the other become too successful.
In politics, a handshake can be an agreement between allies. It can also be a temporary truce between competitors who know that, sooner or later, they will be fighting for the same prize.
Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN
Dear Reader,
Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.
Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.
Donate here:
PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below
Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.
Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.
With gratitude,
The AIMN Team

Good analysis and she’s clearly been promoted by the RW MSM and online ecosystem to deliver electoral talking points*, in now MAGA Tanton Network agitprop (whose SusPopAus divides the centre), so ON divides the right, and pushes further right.
*Masking eugenics of ‘population control’ and Atlas Koch ‘segregation economics’.
That RW MSM and online ecosystem is really cooking passive voters, wall to wall dog whistling of both ALP and Victoria forever…..
One is yet to see any (compelling) analysis, keeping in mind polls and by-elections are not an election, how is ON going to gain urban seats and what will happen in regions vs Nats, and Libs?
If the right parties, which should have this election stitched up, do not sort themselves out vs following skip NewsCorp top down narratives, ALP could pull off a ‘Bradbury’ and a centre left coalition, though unlikely?
I still can’t accept that some good old intellectual nouse; some common sense and some basic IQ has not managed to defeat this frenzy of “ANTI-INTELLECT”! I am seriously disheartened that anyone should actually be trying to analyse the politics of Hatred and Division, in this day and age, after our Humanity came so far to unity and cohesion after WW2.
It seems like everyone is trying to re-establish an appropriate vocabulary; when the whole world sees a f***ing lunatic sidling up with an utter James Bond “Villain”!
When it comes to revolution; ok France has jumped the gun, Spain is on the right path but miles away, UK is right out of the picture probably for their own internecine hatreds; but where the fuck is the UN when we need it most?!
The world is watching a demented lunatic extract billions of tax payers dollars for his own wealth. Where is the ICC, the UN and all those so-called Civilian-based NFP support groups when the empirical US fails to live up to its name and promise?
When Russia can kill Ukraine citizens, without admitting they created the war… Who is there to hear the Ukrainian voices?
Does anyone understand where our global Democratic society really stands???
It doesn’t take a lot to restore democracy. It just takes a number of very passionate individuals, willing to paint the same picture our grandparents painted before losing their own jobs!!!
FFS let’s admit it: When the dumbest University graduate (Taylor) faces the Brightest Fish & Chip Shop Bully (Hanson); NO ONE EXPECTED HANSON TO WIN!!!!
OK, I had no idea our community was so dumb! I never realised that the uneducated F-Tards held so much power. Now that results are clear; I still want to stand up to the dumb Cowboy cunts who appear to be running our agricultural industry and trying to adopt this Bogan style as a Badge of Honour: There is no Badge of Honour in destroying your neighbours and society…
Humanity is not the prime ruler of this planet! Thank God Nature has far more power than our pathetic little rulers! Let’s all look forward to the decline of the dumbest, stupidest, most inane rulers, we have ever seen?!
I disagree, the next test is not the Federal election, it is the Victorian state election.
Of all the Labor governments the Victorian Labor government is the only one I’d give the time of day.
But, the obvious corruption, the attempt to rig elections via electoral funding laws, the state violence directed at protestors of a weapons expo, and the elevation of Zionists above all other Victorians leaves me of the opinion that Vic Labor must be kicked out of office. Victorians would have to have rocks in their heads to walk past that and accept it as the standard.
To make matters worse, for me anyway, Labor have decided to replace Allen with a guy who immediately gives the asset class, the millionaires and billionaires exactly what they wanted and will remove the Land tax. Victoria was the only state that, pre-removal of the CGTdiscount and Negative gearing on new builds, was using tax changes to lessen the growth in house prices.
If the polls are right, and Labor supporters want to avoid 4 years of One Nation and the religion-controlled Coalition, then they should stop flogging a dead horse, and switch their support immediately to the Greens.
Some pollsters are suggesting that people are just tired of the same government, that to re-elect Labor again would be too long in power. I don’t know if that is right, but would suspect that there would be some voters thinking that. This may come down to the wire, and that might be enough.
The Victorian Greens are polling around 19% according to them, that is about the same as the Coalition. If that support jumped up to mid 30’s or even better, the media couldn’t ignore that, and the Vic. Greens have better policies than either One Nation, or the religion-controlled Liberals, and a far, far better voting record.
Those people who rather a progressive government, or voted Labor in the past, but have had enough of Labor, would be given what they could see as a viable option. The Greens have arguably had a more significant influence in the Victorian upper house than in the Federal sphere. Instead of shifting to One Nation and their flunky candidates, voters disenchanted with Labor might start to look more favourably at a surging Greens party.
Is this about to happen? Well, Labor voters have a history of preferencing Liberal candidates ahead of The Greens in order to unseat a Greens MP. Could be a long 4 years for Victorians after November.
In a country where a properly elected peoples government can be dismissed by the Crown!! I’d ask, do we really live in a Democracy?
Thommo, you may disagree… but… I’m talking about federal politics.
Apart from that your comment was valid.
News Corporation promotes One Nation as a welcome support for the currwntly unpopular LNP.
@ jonangel: ”[D]o “WE” really live in a democracy?” Are you now asserting, by association, that you are an Australian person/entity?
@ Michael Taylor: An excellent article, thank you.
The local New England NOtional$ supporters are most likely to rush off to the PHONeys (Profiteering Hanson Only No-one else yet) and there is the possibility of a split conservative vote, which would not assist the aspiring to NOtional$ pre-selection, now former Armidale Mayor with his family backing deeply embedded in that party.
There are many ”Barneys” in the New England electorate. Protected from world political realities by their social isolation and no need to discuss such ”irrelevant topics” as uncouth politics within their personal family circle. There is little reason for them to think that women are required to attend an election polling booth when they, as spouses, can easily do that task for them because they will always vote the same way as themselves.
But how far this admiration of the adulterous, alcoholic, bigoted, corrupt, deceitful, eloper to the PHONeys, philandering, misogynist goes is unknown. The hard facts may be deterministic; PHONeys are NOT offering the unlimited government subsidies for the socialist agricultural industrialists, and financial handouts are usually king.
@ Andrew Smith: An excellent addition to a fine article.
@ Mark Shields: Never underestimate the stupidity of the masses when manipulated by a vert intelligent media baron. We saw it in 1972 Whitlam defeated MacMahon, 1976 Fraser defeated Whitlam, 1983 Hawke defeated Fraser, 1996 Howard defeated Keating, 2007 Rudd defeated Howard. The list goes on.
Do not get mad, get organised and work to insure that Australia is saved from both the horrors of the PHONeys and the incompetence of the LIARBRAL$. The NOtional$ hopefully will be eliminated into long deserved political irrelevance.
NEC, in answer to your question; YES, have been for a long,long time and am proud of it. I take it from your disgruntled comments your are a yank?
Agreed Thommo, the Greens have always had the most sensible and humane policies, but that flies in the face of the duopoly and their commercial masters.I think the biggest barrier to Greens success is the criminally biased MSM, especially the Murdoch trash.The next biggest barrier would be the likes of Albanese &co, who are threatened by ,and shown up by the Greens on many issues.
It’s not hard to imagine that there will be some major changes of mind after the next Federal election.
And Albanese will have a choice,change his mind , or fuck off.
The potential Greens voter and listener is among the small paddock of alert, considering, educated citizens, quite small in numbers and moderate of influence. Brazen brainless bullshitting barging greed at all levels is the typical, headed by a foreign wifedumping taxbludging phonetapping influencebuying powerasserting ex-patriate warthearted anusheadedtransplantmiracle ulcersized bent soul, who owns aggressive media maggoty muckspreading manipulation methodry. Phar Kit!
No need to be so sparing on the ugly old bastard Phil,he is 139 years old, and ranks among the greatest arseholes of the last 100 years.When he finally falls off his golden throne, the cheers will be heard on the dark side of the moon.
@ Phil Pryor: Ooooo!! I love it when you talk dirty!!
@ Harry Lime: Being disgruntled with Alb-Appeasie & his government makes the Greens look a sensible option for 2028. However, polling success requires a concentration of their votes into HoR electorates, and that is unlikely to happen any time soon.
To dream that an APO sweep of the board, as happened in Queensland with the dispatch of the anti-voter Campbell Newman disaster, would require the same dedicated three year campaigning, that the Greens have yet to demonstrate.
Better for the Greens to stay controlling the Senate and excluding the PHONeys from Parliament.
Keeping it all in the PHONeys (Profiteering Hanson Only Naturally easy you see) family – Beetrooter has organised for his bit of fluff, now mother to his two brats, in the PHONeys. Now why is this NOT a surprise??
After a startling career misleading the reading public in the Murdochcracy Media Manipulation Monopoly, it gets her out of the house and back into social circulation.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/oct/13/vikki-campion-news-corp-columnist-and-wife-of-barnaby-joyce-begins-role-with-nsw-one-nation