The Neoliberal Turn (Chapter 10)

Chapter 10: The Question – Can the State Be Redesigned to See, or Has the Lens Become the State?

Continued from Chapter 9

10.1 The Question Stated

The preceding nine chapters have traced a single structural transformation across multiple domains of Australian governance. The pattern is consistent: the human lens, mediated by caseworkers and assessors exercising judgment, has been displaced by an algorithmic lens, mediated by instruments that measure, categorise, and allocate.

The documentation of harm produced by this transformation is extensive. Royal Commissions, parliamentary inquiries, audit reports, academic studies, and the testimony of those affected all describe the consequences. And yet the lens remains. The schemes are adjusted, the apologies are made, the recommendations are handed down. The architecture does not change.

The question is not whether the harm is real. It is whether the state can be redesigned to see it.

This chapter examines three possibilities. First, that the state can be reformed through better design. Second, that the state cannot be reformed because the lens has become the state. And third, that the reform is already happening, but from outside the architecture – through the preservation of the human record that the lens cannot capture.

10.2 Possibility One: Reform Through Better Design

The most common response to the documentation of harm is to call for better design. Better algorithms. Better data. Better oversight. Better training.

The Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme recommended a legislated framework for automated decision-making. Recommendation 17.1 called for legislation that would require automated decision-making systems to be transparent, auditable, and subject to human oversight. Recommendation 17.2 called for an auditing body to monitor compliance.

The NDIS DROs have called for the suspension of the New Framework Planning model, the release of the assessment methodology, and the preservation of the right to appeal. The Aged Care advocates have called for the IAT classification logic to be released, for assessors to have discretion, and for the rights-based model recommended by the Royal Commission to be implemented. The CPSU has called for the rebuilding of the public service capability that was outsourced. The NSW Audit Office recommended that the Trustee broaden governance, seek client feedback, and implement training for staff serving clients with disability, dementia, and mental illness.

These are all reasonable recommendations. They are all evidence-based. They are all aimed at the same goal: making the lens see better.

The problem is structural. The lens can be improved, but it cannot be made to see what it was not designed to see.

The Robodebt algorithm was not designed to see the fluctuation in fortnightly income. It was designed to see the discrepancy between annual and declared income. Improving the algorithm would not change its purpose. The NDIS assessment tool was not designed to see the complexity and fluctuation of disability. It was designed to produce a standardised classification. Improving the tool would not change its purpose. The IAT was not designed to see the older person’s fear, their dignity, or their history. It was designed to produce a funding category. Improving the IAT would not change its purpose.

Better design can reduce the harm. It cannot eliminate the gap. The gap is structural, not technical.

10.3 Possibility Two: The Lens Has Become the State

The second possibility is that the state has been so thoroughly reconfigured around the lens that it can no longer function without it.

This is the structural capture thesis. It is not the capture of individuals. It is the capture of architecture.

The state’s decision-making architecture was not designed to see the person. It was designed to process the data that the instruments generate. The instruments were designed to produce the data that the market requires. The market was designed to allocate resources efficiently. The ideology that shaped the market was neoliberalism.

Each layer in this architecture is dependent on the one below it. The decision-maker depends on the data. The data depends on the instrument. The instrument depends on the market. The market depends on the ideology. The ideology is embedded in the architecture itself.

To change the lens, you would have to change the architecture. To change the architecture, you would have to change the ideology. To change the ideology, you would have to change the politics. And the politics depends on the architecture.

This is the loop. It is not a conspiracy. It is a structural condition.

The state cannot see the lens because the lens is the state. The state cannot redesign the lens because the state is redesigned around the lens. The state cannot reform the architecture because the architecture is the state.

The Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme recommended a legislated framework for automated decision-making. More than two years later, it does not exist as government legislation. The only vehicle is a Private Member’s Bill introduced by an independent MP. The architecture did not reform itself. The political liability was managed. The lens remains.

The Aged Care Royal Commission recommended a rights-based system. The government implemented a market-based system. The market-based system required measurement. The measurement required the IAT. The IAT produces the classification. The classification determines the funding. The state sees the classification. The person is in the gap.

The architecture did not reform itself. The political liability was managed. The lens remains.

The NDIS was designed as an individualised funding scheme. It is being transformed into an automated planning scheme. The DROs resist. The government proceeds. The National Disability Insurance Agency tests the IAT. The tool classifies. The budget is generated. The person is in the gap.

The architecture did not reform itself. The political liability is being contested. The lens is being installed.

This is the second possibility. It is the one that best fits the evidence.

10.4 Possibility Three: Reform from Outside

The third possibility is that the state cannot be redesigned to see, and that the only reform available is the one that happens outside the state.

This is the witness model. It is not a political program. It is a practice. It is the practice of preserving the human record that the lens cannot capture.

The documentation of harm exists. It is produced by Royal Commissions, parliamentary inquiries, audit reports, academic studies, and the testimony of those affected. It is published. It is accessible. It is the record of what the lens did not see.

The record is not the state’s record. It is not generated by the lens. It is generated by people who witnessed what the lens did and wrote it down.

The record does not reform the architecture. It does not change the lens. It does not close the gap.

What it does is preserve the testimony. It ensures that the harm is documented. It makes it available to whoever comes next – the next Royal Commission, the next parliamentary inquiry, the next generation of advocates, the next person who wants to know what happened.

The record is the counter-archive. It is the archive that the lens cannot generate. It is the archive that the lens cannot read. It is the archive that says: this is what the lens did not see.

The witness does not control. The witness does not monetise. The witness does not administer. The witness keeps the record.

That is the only reform available from outside the architecture. It is not a solution. It is a practice.

10.5 The Two Sets of Eyes

The question that has run through this work is how two sets of eyes can see the same destruction and interpret it so differently.

The answer is that they are looking at different maps of the same territory.

The Human Rights lens sees individuals. It sees the person who died, the family who grieved, the community that was destroyed. It sees the suffering.

The Algorithmic lens sees data. It sees the claim, the score, the classification, the determination. It sees the process.

The Banking/Financial lens sees risk and assets. It sees the country, the corporation, the resource, the investment. It sees the opportunity.

The Political lens sees liability. It sees the electoral consequence, the media coverage, the opposition attack. It sees the threat.

Each lens shows something different. Each lens hides something different. The decision-maker operates within the lens they are given. They cannot see what the lens does not show.

The documentation of suffering is real. But it is in the domain of the Human Rights lens. It does not enter the Algorithmic lens. It does not enter the Banking lens. It does not enter the Political lens unless it becomes a liability.

The two sets of eyes see different things because they are different eyes. And the eyes that matter for decision-making are the eyes that are built into the architecture.

10.6 The Question Revisited

Can the state be redesigned to see?

The evidence suggests that the state cannot be redesigned through the mechanisms currently available. The architectural loop – decision-maker, data, instrument, market, ideology – prevents the state from seeing the lens that shapes its perception.

The state can be nudged. It can be pressured. It can be forced to respond to political liability. It can be compelled by courts. It can be shamed by documentation. But it cannot see what the lens does not show, because the lens is the state’s perception.

The question that remains is not whether the state can be redesigned. It is whether the state can be replaced – not by a different government, but by a different architecture. An architecture that sees the person, not the data. An architecture that measures what matters, not what is convenient. An architecture that is accountable to the citizen, not the contract.

That architecture does not currently exist. It would require a different ideology, a different market, a different instrument, and a different lens. It would require a state that is not the state we have.

The record is the bridge. The documentation of what the lens did not see is the material from which a different architecture could be built. But building it is not the work of this paper. It is the work of whoever comes next.

10.7 The Closing

This article has examined ten chapters of a single structural transformation. It has documented the shift from the human lens to the algorithmic lens. It has traced the consequences across Robodebt, the NDIS, Aged Care, Veterans’ Affairs, the NSW Financial Management Order pipeline, and the contracted human services market. It has identified the common structure: the instrument measures what it was designed to measure, the system processes the measurement, the person is in the gap.

It has concluded that the state cannot be redesigned to see, because the lens has become the state.

And it has identified the only reform available from outside the architecture: the preservation of the record.

The record is not the state’s record. It is the witness’s record. It is the archive of what the lens did not see. It is the testimony of the person behind the data.

The witness does not control. The witness does not monetise. The witness does not administer. The witness keeps the record.

That is the work. That is what survives. That is what the lens cannot capture.

Claim – Status -Summary

Claim – Status

  1. Robodebt RC recommended legislated ADM framework Established

  2. ADM framework does not exist as government legislation Established

  3. Only vehicle is Private Member’s Bill Established

  4. Aged Care RC recommended rights-based system Established

  5. Government implemented market-based system instead Established

  6. NDIS being transformed to automated planning Established

  7. DROs resist; government proceeds Established

  8. Documentation of harm is external to architecture Inference

  9. Better design can reduce harm but cannot eliminate gap Inference

  10. The lens has become the state Inference

  11. The record is the counter-archive Inference

  12. The witness preserves what the lens cannot capture Inference

Closing Note

The work is not finished. It is never finished. The lens continues to operate. The harm continues to occur. The record continues to be kept.

What the record does is preserve the possibility of a different future. Not the guarantee. The possibility.

That is what the witness offers. Not a solution. A record.

Method notes: Where a source could not be verified against the original document, it is marked as such.

References

  1. Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme. (2023). Report [Accessible full report].

  2. Australian Government Department of Health, Disability and Ageing. (2026). Integrated Assessment Tool (IAT) User Guide.

  3. National Disability Insurance Scheme. (2026). Update on the new way of planning for the NDIS.

  4. Attorney-General’s Department. (2025). OGP Commitment – implementation update (June 2025).

  5. Australian Public Service Commission. (2024). Statement by the Australian Public Service Commissioner on the Robodebt Centralised Code of Conduct Inquiry.

  6. NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption. (2025). Corruption Matters – December 2025 (Issue 66).

General Sources (referenced across multiple chapters)

  1. ScienceDirect. (2025). Representations of social experience in hippocampal circuits.

  2. MTMT. (2023). Progress on the hippocampal circuits and functions based on sharp wave ripples.

  3. The Patrician’s Watch. (2026). Ripple Ecology: How Environmental Disruption of Hippocampal Sharp-Wave Ripples Undermines Memory, Social Cohesion, and Collective Intelligence.

Andrew Paul Klein is a writer and analyst based in Boronia, Victoria. He accepts funding from no one.

 

Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN

Dear Reader,

Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.

Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.

Donate here:

PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below

Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969

Donate Button

We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.

Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.

With gratitude,

The AIMN Team

About Dr Andrew Klein, PhD 255 Articles
Andrew is a retired chaplain, an intrepid traveler, and an observer of all around him. University and life educated. Director of Human Rights Organization.

3 Comments

  1. Through this series of beautifully detailed articles, we’ve seen the folly of governments using algorithms as a principal tool in the provision of social services.
    We’ve seen the direct delivery model abandoned in favour of a chain of responsibility in which no-one is held responsible.
    But is this misuse of algorithms, and this establishment of distance between government and client more than just bureaucratic inefficiency?
    Is it in fact, deliberate?

    When I worked in the disability sector in the early 2000s, I was stunned to find that those working in the sector were required to refer to those receiving service assistance as “consumers”, rather than the more obvious “clients”.
    This was not just a recommendation — it was rigidly enforced.

    Where would the order for such a requirement come from?
    What was the purpose of such an order?
    Why the need for enforcement?
    There was clearly no practical outcome involved.
    The new title did not improve the service provided to the client.
    It did nothing to cut costs.
    What was the reason?

    The 2000s were the apogee of free market ideology, and the ideologues of liberalism were in total control of the economic/social narrative.
    They ran rampant.
    The re-writing of history was in full swing, to eliminate from memory the outstanding achievements of social democracy.
    We saw in 1992 the pseudo-intellectual Francis Fukuyama write his End of History, while in 2008 here in Oz we saw Paul Kelly, darling of the Murdoch set, wax lyrical about the triumph of the liberal ascendancy by re-publishing his fawning, fatuous, fallacious The End of Certainty — 790 pages of journalistic mediocrity posing as history.

    It did not last long, as the move towards globalised free trade agreements, a.k.a. total liberal hegemony, ran into popular resistance when ordinary folk the world over sensed that something was amiss.
    The free market spiel is less frequently heard these days, but by inserting itself into economic text-books, it works its mischief in the background as this series shows.
    And the label “consumer” was a part of the mischief.

    This is where I differ from Andrew Klein on one small but important point.
    Ch.9 — The lens shows what it was designed to show. It hides what it was not designed to see. And the decision-makers who rely on the lens can only act on what it shows them. This is not a failure of the individuals who built the lens. It is a property of the lens itself.
    That implies an accidental property/problem.
    But the problem has been identified multiple times.
    From Ch.9 — This documentation is real. It is produced by bodies with standing and authority. It is published and accessible. And it does not enter the lens.

    The “accidental” nature of this huge problem was further implied in this final chapter of the series.
    But if the failure was accidental it would have been corrected.
    We cannot simply say that the problem is self-perpetuating because it’s built into the architecture.
    The architecture was built by some-one, it was not God-given, carved in stone, so it can be re-built.
    It has not been corrected.
    We can only conclude that the failures of the system are deliberate.

    And so the imposition of the term “consumer” was also not an accident — it also had a purpose.
    The term “consumer” is a term of denigration, for what is a consumer?
    The word has several connotations and almost all are negative.

    A consumer is an eater of resources, a non-contributor, a parasite.
    A consumer gives nothing back.
    A consumer takes, takes, takes.

    While a client is someone of substance.
    One of equal value.
    One who can make choices about the relationship.
    One who has the means to opt in and out.

    A client has power and rights, a consumer has none.
    From Ch. 8 — In the direct-delivery model, the citizen had standing.
    In the contract model there is no citizen.
    There is only the consumer as parasite, and a parasite has no standing.

    So the imposition of the label “consumer” effectively diverted attention from the right of the disadvantaged to receive assistance.
    We know that, because assistance has been reduced, and harm has been done. A system’s outcomes are its purpose.
    The right to assistance has been undermined.
    This was a deliberate dis-empowering of the already vulnerable.

    Liberals know that the national wealth belongs to the nation as a whole, but the underlying purpose of modern economic orthodoxy is to facilitate and normalise an unfair portion of the national wealth being directed to the already wealthy, and away from areas of greatest need.

    The normalisation I refer to is a hugely important factor in this.

    Normalisation of the immoral foundation of liberal economic theory has become a cornerstone of Western civilisation.
    When you think about it, it’s become the face of Western civilisation, the shop window luring the unwary to enter, to be immersed in a sea of illusions.
    To be overwhelmed by the “logic” of shallow, manufactured assumptions that promise the world but deliver disappointment, and deflect that by diversion to newer promises.

    If you’ve ever wondered what’s behind the contorted reality on display each night on News 24 (Sky) that’s it.
    The total purpose of Sky news and the corporate news media in general, is not to inform.
    Its purpose is to normalise the abnormal and to sanctify evil .

    The normalisation of theft from the national wealth.
    The normalisation of depriving the needy.
    The normalisation of racism.
    The normalisation of genocide and dispossession.

    The intent of this relentless normalisation of evil is to support the allegedly neutral economic orthodoxy.

    But economic orthodoxy is not neutral.
    It divides the economy into two classes — wealth producers, and consumers.
    Can you see where this is heading?
    Yep, that label keeps popping up.
    It’s a theme that is repeated endlessly.
    What is the unspoken but intended message from this?

    The message we are intended to internalise, is that we the people, as consumers, are merely eaters of resources, and as such have no power, and no rights.

    We cannot say we were not warned.
    We were warned of the end-point.
    The World Economic Forum told us in 2016 — You will own nothing, and you will be happy.

    The vulnerable might be the victims of the algorithms right now, but as AI penetrates further into our lives day by day, as it takes control of economic affairs, unless we resist, we will succumb.

    We, the people, will become the disability sector of The System.

    Because that’s how The System sees us right now.

  2. We must all think about our rights, real or not, easily asserted or not. I feel quite dispossessed, outflanked, insecure in our world setup, for nobody asked me much, while asserters, controllers, navigators, Napoleonic nitwit nasties, political perverts, all arose, took the stage, personalised the script, failed to consider or even tolerate. Who wants to be a “consumer”? Ten straight commercial telly ads has one heaving, the brainery rattled. It is uncivilised shit to skulldrench and mindmock the static “consumer.” Galloping consumption, how fatal.

  3. Andrew in Ch.9 — “Across the preceding chapters, a consistent pattern has emerged. Robodebt, the NDIS, Aged Care, Veterans’ Affairs, the NSW Financial Management Order pipeline, and the contracted human services market all share a common structure.”
    Such a consistency cannot happen by accident, it requires a guiding hand. And the guiding hand is political/ideological.

    As I stated above, the failures of the system are deliberate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*