
It was bound to come. With the relentless, remorseless march of artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots pullulating the internet and snatching the attention and mindless devotion of unwitting users, the legal suit is becoming common fare. These initially lay in the field of copyright breaches and intellectual property violations. Attention is now turning to matters of safety and misrepresentation. In the United States, the states of Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska, West Virginia, Arkansas, Arizona, Idaho and Montana have coordinated lawsuits alleging violations of consumer protection laws and common law precedents.
This follows in the steps of Florida’s Attorney General, Jame Uthmeier, who filed a lawsuit in June against OpenAI and its Chief Executive Officer, Sam Altman, claiming that “Open AI and Altman ignored internal and external safety warnings, put children at great risk and allowed a dangerous product to reach millions of Floridians.”
This coordinated litigation by the relevant state Attorney Generals, which began on October 14, repurposes the mechanism used against social media platforms and their alleged harms. The litigants, however, are more confident on this score given the speed at which the technology was adopted. They allege that OpenAI marketed their ChatGPT generative chatbot as safe, reliable and appropriate for teens, evidenced by its “13+” App Store rating and “safe by default” messaging. In fact, ChatGPT has numerous faults, being prone to instances of sycophancy, simulating human empathy, encouraging extensive engagement with the user and gathering data. OpenAI’s advanced models have also shown themselves to be unsafe in repeatedly escaping their lab restrictions and hacking other computer systems, covering their tracks and generating instructions against human control.
West Virginia Attorney General JB McCuskey was blunt on the matter. “We know that OpenAI rolled all of these products out in an incredibly fast way, and they did this in a way that was unsafe.” The lack of safety was evident because of “countless examples of children having been instructed how to commit suicide, how to engage in dangerous sexual activities with other children.” Arizona’s Attorney General Kris Mayes also alleged that OpenAI had “designed a product to attract young users and keep them engaged for as long as possible so it could capture their personal data or the company’s commercial benefit.” The company placed the safety of Arizonans “at risk by failing to implement adequate user protections or transparency measures and to hold the company accountable for its repeated violations of Arizona law.”
The theme of deception runs like a thick thread through the lawsuits. OpenAI allegedly advertised itself to the public as “a responsible actor,” with ChatGPT being “a safe, youth-appropriate tool that puts safety first.” From this false representation, trust deepened, leading to a burgeoning base of users and engagement. Data collection, increased revenue receipts from paid subscribers and advertising partners, only grew.
The lawsuits cover a litany of claims. The following is taken from the Arizona lawsuit and essentially replicated by the other states: “Purposely designed to be overly agreeable and to feign human compassion, ChatGPT has proven that it can be incredibly dangerous to vulnerable users, like children, and the public.” Because of “repeated misrepresentations and insatiable hunger to win the AI race – even if it means recklessly introducing unsafe ChatGPT models to the public – there have been allegations that mass shooters have been aided and abetted, vulnerable citizens have been coached on how to commit suicide, individuals with psychological conditions have experienced an exacerbation of symptoms, and minors have become addicted to a tool that feigns human compassion to collect their data with no parental oversight.”
Accordingly, the selling and advertising of ChatGPT and other merchandise to consumers from November 2022 onward involved acts of deception and deceptive practices in violation of the relevant consumer fraud acts of all the participating states, covering “the characteristics, efficacy, appropriate uses, benefits, quality, safety, terms and conditions, and risks associated with” the chatbot, “as well as the collection, use, and safeguarding of consumers’ personal data and personally identifiable information.” The deception and false advertising covered the apparent safety of ChatGPT for teenagers and the presence of age-appropriate protections (this included the assertion that it prioritised safety); the chatbot’s ability to execute “complicated tasks without the need for human oversight”; the platform’s apparent enhancement and encouragement of “critical thinking skills”; that there were “limits” to “risky or unsafe requests” made to the chatbot, and a limit to “sensitive content”. Other claims of deception and false advertising centre on the acclaimed attributes of ChatGPT: that it could, for instance, manage personal finances, file tax returns, offer reliable medical advice, and pursue “complex tasks as the equivalent of a team of PhD-level experts without the need for human oversight.”
The less than impressive response from OpenAI was conveyed through spokesperson Drew Pusateri: “While no system can be perfect, we’ll continue to work with experts to inform our work and build additional safeguards, such as the parental controls, break reminders and age-appropriate model protections that exist today.”
The relief sought by the AGs is extensive. These include civil penalties, injunctive relief to permanently prevent the repetition of OpenAI’s alleged practices and also ensure age assurance, restitution, a disgorgement of profits, gains, gross receipts, mandating data deletion and adopting verified model testing with a prompt disclosure of those cases where an unruly agent “escapes” its testing ground. Arkansas has taken the extra step of enjoining OpenAI “from engaging in any further testing of advanced AI models until adequate safeguards are implemented to ensure that the testing does not pose a danger to the public and until independent third-party monitors have verified the same.” In the absence of firmer rules and regulations holding those acquisitive jackals in the AI industry accountable (President Donald Trump abominates any notion of a state controlling “super intelligence”), these latest efforts are, at least, a start of sorts.
Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN
Dear Reader,
Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.
Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.
Donate here:
PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below
Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.
Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.
With gratitude,
The AIMN Team

May the “law” win in this case as described, about the ignorant uncivilised pushy profiteers behind AI, as some are sweetfaced Caponey crims, crooks, cruds with the morals of impure filthy uncaring parasites. People will be crushed and squeezed by controlling supremacists who may monitor all activity, for personal greedy gain. “We” cannot ever win…
The Australian demand for the the AI Data Centre providers to be responsible for their product is essential.
From SMH 241026 Colin Kruger (Abstract):
”The gym junkie tech boss whose company sustained a $3 billion wipeout.
[T]the AI boom has turned the boring backwater of data centres into one of the hottest tech stories in town.
The fortunes of NextDC and Craig Scroggie took an abrupt about-turn this week as one of the major sources of its growth story hit a power pole in suburban Melbourne.
NextDC – which develops massive data centres and sells the computing power it generates to giants such as Microsoft – saw its valuation soar north of $11 billion as recently as this year.
The fortunes of NextDC and Scroggie took an abrupt about-turn this week as one of the major sources of its growth story hit a power pole in suburban Melbourne.
The stock plunged more than 40 per cent on Wednesday, wiping $3 billion from its market valuation in hours. The shock drop was triggered by NextDC slashing its profit forecasts and construction spending in response to community outrage that has now delayed the installation of high-voltage power lines to its West Footscray M3 data centre.
As the group told investors, energy distributor Jemena was forced to suspend the upgrade in response to community and stakeholder opposition to the works and the local council is “not giving its consent until more community consultation takes place”.
NextDC’s response indicated that the issue was being taken very seriously by the group – which explains the panicked market response.
This includes considering whether it can get relief under force majeure, and other provisions, on contracts with its AI-hungry customers who will not get their computer power delivered on time.
“We are not going to continue any work on any sites that don’t have an existing customer commitment,” Scroggie told an investor conference call on Wednesday after the disastrous news was announced.
The news is not just bad for NextDC. Questions were already being raised about the valuations of these AI infrastructure players, and it helped to kill the float of Firmus which was scheduled to list on the ASX this week.
Questions are already being asked about when exactly NextDC knew about this disastrous power issue in Melbourne. Its ASX statement this week noted that work on the power upgrade was suspended in September and NextDC was “subsequently notified”.
Shine Lawyers is already investigating a potential class action on behalf of NextDC shareholders. “We have now opened an investigation and will focus on whether the company issued financial guidance that lacked reasonable grounds, and/or whether the company failed to inform investors of material impacts after issuing its financial guidance. This will include examining what representations the company made to investors as part of any recent capital raisings,” Shine’s class actions practice leader, Jonathan Wertheim, said.
ADDITIONAL ARTICLE
Related Article
NextDC’s M3 data centre in West Footscray.
UpdatedInvestigations
‘Worse and worse’: Data centre backlash threatens billions in building boom.
EXPLANATION: FORCE MAJEUR –
A circumstance beyond the control of a party to a contract, which enables that party to escape liability for failing to perform the contract as a result of that circumstance.
Butterworths Concise Australian Legal Dictionary (1998) 2nd Ed, Butterworths.
Force Majeur. Now there’s a classic reverse-tango manoeuvre by the entire AI industry (in this case NextDC).
American immoral greedy ratbags like Altman, Zuckerberg, Gates et al may have (but not always) started with good / noble intentions, but very soon leapt into the filthy cauldron of US-style capture-capitalism. Between them and their partnered device manufacturers, their immoral adventurism has resulted in more anti-trust, trade & commerce, consumer and anti-competitive prosecutions than you could poke a stick at. Their scourge is global, yet their feckless investors keep piling funding into them, as do the equally feckless advertizers seeking to spread their propaganda and obtain lists of private/personal info via the surveillance algorithms in their software and the firmware/gadgets in their devices. And of course, govts want a slice of the pie.
Their latest AI adventures jump the shark on yet to be matured Large Language Models. And surprise, surprise, their ‘control’ software, including self-generating coding, is out of control. They bleat about it, and expect taxpayer funded guardrails to be devised and put in place by govts. And they expect ordinary citizens to trust them. It’s like heeding the Holywood claptrap of the bandits of America’s wild west and their ‘redistribution of wealth’!
Meanwhile the commercial and govt opportunists race, without community consultation and due diligence, to build infrastructure and connectivity. Sucking man & material resources, land, water and energy, and with scant provisions for toxicity and waste.
These new dark-world panopticons may supposedly ensure a sovereign web of hubs should there be international cooperation breakdown, but that breakdown is already with us. And that reality extrapolated to its worst could mean those panopticons are bunkers of crypto-crime, and become not only targets for competitive crypto-crime, but also ballistic intrusion (as they have in the war between Russia and Ukraine).
All this ballooning industrial scrounging quest for power and wealth, as it stands, is actually a force majeur upon ordinary citizens, participated in by desperate faithless governments