
I watched a short clip of Miranda Devine attempting to explain why younger women dislike Donald Trump.
It was awful.
Not “controversial.” Not “provocative.” Just awful – in the way that makes you sit back and think: Did she really just say that out loud?
What follows is the full transcript, cleaned only for readability, followed by a forensic critique. No straw men. No exaggeration. No need. The words are bad enough on their own.
The transcript
“A bit more on TDS, because it seems to inflict – certainly in my experience – women particularly harshly.
And I’ve always wondered if it’s because they have, you know, for want of a better term, daddy issues, because Trump is sort of unabashedly male.
He’s very sort of paternal or patriarch, or whatever you like – he’s an alpha male – which I guess has been almost stamped out because of toxic masculinity tropes and so on.
And young girls maybe don’t have a father.
They grow up thinking that men have to be, you know, castrati, as you mentioned.
Is that part of the problem – that Trump’s just too alpha male?
So I’m not sure if I would link it to sort of a Freudian daddy issue.”
That is not paraphrase.
That is not satire.
That is the argument.
What this argument actually does (not what it pretends to do)
This is not political analysis. It is gendered delegitimisation, a tactic so old it should arrive in sepia tones.
1. Political disagreement becomes psychological defect
Women don’t dislike Trump because of his record, behaviour, criminality, authoritarianism, or contempt for democracy.
No – they dislike him because they are:
- afflicted by Trump Derangement Syndrome
- emotionally damaged
- victims of absent fathers
Disagreement is not allowed to exist as reasoned judgement. It must be medicalised.
2. Women’s agency quietly disappears
Notice the language:
- “conditioned”
- “inflicts”
- “grow up thinking”
- “maybe don’t have a father”
Women are not thinking actors here. They are products of damage.
Men who oppose Trump are political opponents.
Women who oppose Trump are psychological case studies.
That distinction is doing all the work.
3. “Alpha male” is smuggled in as virtue
Let’s be clear about what “alpha male” means in this context.
It does not mean:
- competence
- integrity
- leadership
- restraint
It means:
- dominance
- unapologetic power
- refusal to be challenged
- expectation of submission
Disagreement, therefore, becomes emasculation. Criticism becomes pathology.
4. Absent fathers → broken women → invalid opinions
This is the ugliest part. The logic chain is:
- some women didn’t have fathers
- therefore they are hostile to male authority
- therefore their political judgement is unreliable
This isn’t analysis. It’s social sorting – deciding whose opinions count based on family structure and gender.
Victorian hysteria theory, now with podcast microphones.
Why this collapses instantly under scrutiny
It is unfalsifiable by design
If a woman explains her reasons for opposing Trump, that explanation itself is reclassified as a symptom. No evidence can ever disprove the claim – which tells you everything you need to know about its intellectual seriousness.
It selectively pathologises one group
If this were genuine psychology, she would have to ask:
- Why don’t men with “daddy issues” show TDS?
- Why don’t women react this way to other male leaders?
- Why does opposition correlate with education, media literacy, and democratic values rather than father absence?
She doesn’t ask – because the answers break the frame.
It inverts cause and effect
Women don’t reject Trump because he’s “too male”. They reject him because he:
- degrades women publicly
- boasts about sexual assault
- treats loyalty as submission
- punishes dissent
Calling that rejection “castration anxiety” is projection, not insight.
What this is really for
This kind of commentary has a function. It tells men: Don’t listen to women who oppose Trump – they’re damaged.
It tells women: If you object, you’re proving the diagnosis.
It inoculates the audience against women’s political judgement before it’s even heard. That’s not debate. That’s pre-emptive dismissal.
The short version (because it deserves one)
Women who oppose Trump are not thinking. They are traumatised, fatherless, emotionally unstable, and hostile to male authority – and therefore can be ignored.
That is the argument. Everything else is garnish.
Final note
When political commentary reaches for “daddy issues” instead of evidence, it isn’t being brave or anti-PC. It’s just revealing how thin the argument has become.
And, as ever, facts remain the leading cause of injury in certain media environments.
Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN
Dear Reader,
Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless voice for truth, giving public interest journalists a platform to hold power to account. From expert analysis on national and global events to uncovering issues that matter to you, we’re here because of your support.
Running an independent site isn’t cheap, and rising costs mean we need you now more than ever. Your donation – big or small – keeps our servers humming, our writers digging, and our stories free for all.
Join our community of truth-seekers. Donate via PayPal or credit card via the button below, or bank transfer [BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969] and help us keep shining a light.
With gratitude, The AIMN Team

Put more simply – they don’t like him because he’s a prick!
That’s certainly what my daughters and other women – both young and old – that I know tell me.
And I agree…. he is.
M Devine is the daughter of F Devine, a deceased professional shitsprayer who squirted forwards for you and you’d need to stay well behind. Frank was versatile.., he could have worked for Adolf, Josef, Rupert, all getting value for applied hatred, ridicule, oneupmanship. Truth? Honesty? Decency? even Law? All was irrelevant to the Devine projection of rented outrage. Miranda studied some maths apparently, thus is expert at nearly everything else. Domiciled overseas ( Australia is beneath her) she continues the well paid shittery; filth and fiction make her happy. Her charm and ability are entirely imaginary. And, Trump remains a dopey dogbowel. While people are submerged in religion, superstition, fantasy, illusion, righteousness, egofixations, we are stuffed.
Miranda Devine being granted status as an objective and legitimate commentator will be the day when journalism has well & truly jumped the shark.
Nah… rephrase that. Journalism’s already jumped the shark. Devine’s merely a relic artefact existing as a constant reminder of how bad things got and why MSM, particularly of the Murdochian variety, ought to be avoided like the plague.
I note that Albo has been invited by Mad Donald to join “the Gaza Board of Peace” We know that Trump lives in a parallel universe, but this defies all sanity.The POTUS is way past locking up.
If Albanese hasn’t sent him an autographed picture of his arse,he should resign now.
We’d be better off dealing with that slit eyed halfwit Vance…or would we?
Just as well she’s left the country, given her unthoughtful presence.