On the 8th May 1945, Germany surrendered unconditionally to the Allies. On the 9th May 2025, Russia is holding a grand commemoration – a “Victory Day” for the 80th anniversary of this event. How dare they? I know, from my extensive cinema history, that the Americans won World War 2.
Many exciting and entertaining movies have been made, over the decades, glorifying the courage and success of the good soldiers on the good side – several allied nations, notably the British. But my favourites were always from Hollywood. There were so many, and of course, I haven’t seen them all.
From early on, there were movies like The Story of G.I. Joe, Dive Bomber, So Proudly We Hail! and Sahara. And During World War 2, Disney made films for every branch of the United States Armed Forces and government.
Hollywood downplayed the efforts and contributions of the other Allies. But some films grudgingly acknowledged the United Kingdom, who kept the hopeless fight alive until the USA joined in and saved the day. Non-European Allies are mostly never even mentioned, especially China, with its pivotal role in the war against Japan. The Soviet-German war on the Eastern Front, if mentioned at all, is sometimes portrayed as a sideshow.
Some movies based on real events, such as the film U571 are about real persons who were not American, depicted them as Americans. U571 (2000) is about American submariners. ‘Red Tails‘ (2012) is a great exaggeration about American airmen. In some movies, we learn that WWII only began only on December 7, 1941, when the United States entered the war. Some movies are such fun, even if fictional, for example the Americans killing Hitler in Inglourious Basterds.
Many movies are about the overall war effort, but focus on America’s involvement. Some of these films include Saving Private Ryan (1998) Flags of Our Fathers (2006), and the mini series Band of Brothers (2001). Films on the D Day landings give the impression that the American landing on Omaha Beach was the decisive turning point that led to Allied victory in Europe.
Now, I know that I’m pretty right, in claiming that the Americans won World War 2. In our democratic culture we accept the opinions of the many. The more common view is now that the Americans were the primary reason for the Nazi defeat, with 40-52% in America and Europe saying so. (But Britons do think it was the UK). But back to when the war ended:
“In 1945, 57% of French citizens believed Moscow “contributed most to the defeat of Germany in 1945” – just 20% named the US, and 12% Britain. By 2015, less than a quarter of respondents recognised the Soviet role, with 54% believing the US to be Nazism’s ultimate vanquisher. Today only 17-28% of Europeans and Americans suggest that the USSR did the bulk of the work in bringing down Hitler.”
If you go to Encyclopedia Britannica, or Wikipedia, or many history sites, you are told some extraordinary facts and figures about the role of the Soviet Union in World War 2. And they attribute the defeat of Nazi Germany as being mainly achieved by the Russians, with substantial input from Britain and the USA.
For example: “The Eastern Front was decisive in determining the outcome in the European theatre of operations in World War 2, eventually serving as the main reason for the defeat of Nazi Germany The decisive battles were Stalingrad, Kursk, and the Battle of Berlin.”
You find this sort of information: “The Soviet Union lost at least 26 million in World War 2, Considerably more than any other country. Russian casualties were 60 times the number of American casualties… More Russian died at Stalingrad than Americans and Britons died in the whole war.”
D Day 6 June 1944, was a big day in bringing the war towards the end. Approximately 156,000 Allied troops landed in Normandy, France, of which nearly half were from the USA. Additionally, smaller contingents of troops from other allied countries were also involved. So at least the various historical records agree that the USA was strongly involved in the eventual victory, even though they joined in the war effort only in December 1941.
But now, it’s time to correct the records on who defeated the Nazis. Britain and Europe are doing their best, holding VE Day celebrations, in which Russia is excluded. And now, Donald Trump has issued a proclamation designating Thursday as a day for the United States to celebrate its victory in the war: “… we did more than any other Country, by far, in producing a victorious result on World War II.”
President Donald Trump is busily correcting historical records, taking over the National Archives, or as he puts it; RESTORING TRUTH AND SANITY TO AMERICAN HISTORY.
So, between the entertainment culture, the political views of the Western Powers, and finally, no less a history expert than Donald Trump himself, we can hope that all that nonsense about Russia winning WW2 can be put to bed.
Independent sites such as The AIMN provide a platform for public interest journalists. From its humble beginning in January 2013, The AIMN has grown into one of the most trusted and popular independent media organisations.
One of the reasons we have succeeded has been due to the support we receive from our readers through their financial contributions.
With increasing costs to maintain The AIMN, we need this continued support.
Your donation – large or small – to help with the running costs of this site will be greatly appreciated.
You can donate through PayPal or credit card via the button below, or donate via bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
Picture this: the leader of the free world, mid-interview, sipping an iced tea (or maybe…
Well, there have been quite a bit of commentary on how gracious the ex-Opposition leader…
La Trobe University Media Release ONLINE PANEL DISCUSSION: How will a newly emboldened Albanese government…
Following Tim Wilson’s unexpected election victory, we’ve seen a surge in views for our Tim…
By Kathryn It makes me want to choke on my toast (with irony and cynical…
The Liberal Party headquarters resembled a ghost town after their crushing election defeat. The air…
View Comments
His pal Putin should slap him down on that.
Came across this the other day -- "there is a floor to reality which is why its called reality....that floor is the fact it does not go away even when you deny its existence."
The US really does believe the Hollywood hype.
Remember the incident just a few years back when a bunch of drongos who thought they were in a Rambo movie sailed down to Venezuela to kidnap the President?
They were rounded up by Venezuelan security before they got their feet wet.
And just today US naval power had to call for a truce with Yemen after attacks on US navy vessels caused the loss of three fighter jets falling overboard.
Not to mention Yemen downing about twenty drones valued at about $30million each.
Reality is that which does not go away.
Americans keep choosing to forget and/or deny historical fact! The reality is that WW2 started on 1st September, 1939 when Hitler's horrendous Nazi regime decided to invade Poland!
The FACT is that WW2 was raging for nearly SIX LONG YEARS before the Americans even saw a minute's combat. The Yanks didn't seem to give a rat's behind that the Nazis invaded Poland; the TRUTH is that the Americans turned their backs, shrugged their shoulders and left Europe to its "own devises" NOT bothering to get involved in World War 2 right up to and until December 8, 1945 the day AFTER the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbour. Needless to say that the American "involvement" in WW2 didn't happen until almost THREE YEARS after 19 February, 1942 when the Japanese bombed the northern Australian city of Darwin!
History has shown that America only gets involved when its OWN self-interests are impacted or threatened - they rarely, if ever, get involved in wars that threaten other hapless nations. As such, the self-centred, fictitious American DELUSION that they, single-handedly, won WW2 is a load of unadulterated BS! Australia, the UK and most of Europe are NOT buying it because, unlike America, WE WERE THERE defending Poland, the UK and most of Europe for more than SIX LONG YEARS when America was NOT!
The chest-beating arrogance and ignorance of deluded Americans, like that pompous megalomaniacal psychopath, Trump, is staggering! Americans continually choose to live in their own parallel universe; believe their own lies and twisted, self-promoting, fictional view of the world and its skewed view of history. Sadly, Americans are so quick to believe all the crap they inhale from their biased media; so easily manipulated by the excessive, rather nauseating, level of flag-waving nationalism and very quick to take credit for the hard work, risks and life-threatening combat that courageous soldiers from OTHER nations have undertaken in many conflicts that have threatened the world. America and Australia only get involved in distractionary wars - like Vietnam and America's ILLEGAL invasion of Iraq - when the right-wing war mongers in the Republican movement and their sycophantic allies in Australia's LNP - want to take attention away from their own appalling level of self-serving corruption! The fact that the American puppet, John Howard, was so willing to sacrifice the lives of young Australians to appease that internationally-discredited war criminal, George W Bush, has brought shame and notoriety to our nation!
America is a nation that consistently PROVES the truth in the foresightful quote from Aeschylus which states, "In war, truth is the first casualty".
Let's hope that Australia NEVER AGAIN blindly follows America into senseless wars and needless combat with nations that do not directly threaten us.
Kathryn, I think you'll find that Pearl Harbour was 1941, so 2 years into the war not 6.
Churchill asked Roosevelt for help in 1940, and the USA agreed to send more destroyers to Britain in exchange for a deal on bases for 99 years. He announced to the American public that they would NOT be entering the war as combatants. They only joined in when Japan attacked Pearl Harbour in order to cripple the US fleet so their expansion into the Pacific would be easier.
We cannot deny that the involvement of the US in both European and Pacific theatres made a difference to the defeat of both axis powers, but their denial that any other effort was secondary is disingenuous. The Russian front was the beginning of the end for Hitler.
What bothers me the most about WWII is that the Allies all knew what was happening to Jews very early in the war, and they ignored it.
It's also important to provide the context that the Soviet Union sided with the Nazis to start WW2
The Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact. It's another fact often glossed over.
In this context its also reasonable to point out that Putin is on the record as justifying/rationalising Hitler's position in starting WW2
A non-aggression pact started WW2?
It looks as though it's not only Hollywood re-writing history.
An agreement to divide Poland, which allowed the Nazis to invade, started WW2
You can blame Stalin for that, AC. Any general who tried to warn him that the Nazis couldn’t be trusted was taken out and shot.
It’s also worth remembering that after war broke out in Europe the American sentiments were with Germany. Some wealthy Americans were even funding them. One such benefactor spawned two American presidents.
Yes, there were plenty in the US that either wanted to keep out, or overtly supported the Nazis.
There's no denying those facts.
It also seems to be the case that plenty of people are either ignorant about the Molotov Ribbentrop Pact, or gloss over it.
But can you imagine the outrage in any other country if the contemporary leader provided support/context/justification for Hitler's rationale?