
When justice becomes a spectacle: the barbarity of livestreamed execution
There are moments when a society reveals something about itself that is far more disturbing than the crime that prompted its response.
The decision to execute a condemned man by firing squad is one such moment. The decision to livestream that execution to a potentially enormous audience takes the matter somewhere else entirely.
It turns death into a spectacle.
Nidal Hasan, the former US Army psychiatrist convicted of killing 13 people and wounding 32 others in the 2009 Fort Hood shooting, is scheduled to be executed by firing squad on December 3. The Pentagon has announced that the execution will be livestreamed, with US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth arguing that people need to understand there are serious consequences for such crimes.
There is no question about the appalling nature of Hasan’s crime. Thirteen people lost their lives, dozens more were injured, and families were left to live with the consequences of an act of extraordinary violence.
Their suffering deserves recognition. Their loved ones deserve remembrance. Justice must take the gravity of such crimes seriously.
But acknowledging the horror of a crime does not require us to suspend our capacity to question what is done in its name.
And that is where this decision becomes deeply troubling.
What, precisely, are we supposed to learn by watching a human being shot to death?
If the purpose is to demonstrate that murder has consequences, the criminal conviction, the sentence and the years spent on death row have already made that point. If the purpose is to reassure the public that the justice system is carrying out its sentence, there are ways to provide accountability without turning the final moments of a condemned man into a broadcast event.
What does the camera add?
What public good is served by allowing potentially millions of people to watch the deliberate destruction of a human life?
We are told that such a display might serve as a warning. Yet there is something profoundly unsettling about the suggestion that the sight of a person being executed is an appropriate educational experience for the public.
Are we attempting to discourage violence by making violence available for public consumption?
And if that is the lesson, what exactly are we teaching?
There is a difference between reporting that an execution has taken place and inviting the world to watch it happen. One informs the public. The other risks turning death into entertainment, however solemnly the organisers might insist otherwise.
A firing squad is not an abstract legal concept. It involves human beings deliberately using lethal force against another human being. Whatever the arguments about its efficiency or reliability, there is nothing sanitised about its purpose. Someone is going to die because the state has decided that death is the punishment.
We can debate the morality of capital punishment, the rights of victims, the responsibilities of governments and the obligations of the justice system. Those are legitimate questions in any society that claims to value human dignity.
But broadcasting an execution introduces another question: when does the administration of justice become a performance designed for an audience?
For centuries, public executions attracted crowds. People gathered to witness hangings and other forms of state-sanctioned killing, sometimes treating them as public entertainment. Authorities could present these events as warnings to would-be offenders, while spectators came to watch the spectacle of a person meeting their death.
Civilisation eventually moved away from that practice in the United States. Executions became private proceedings, witnessed by a limited number of authorised observers rather than performed before a crowd.
Now ‘we’ are being asked to consider the possibility of bringing that spectacle back, this time with the reach of modern technology.
The difference is that the crowd no longer needs to assemble in a town square. It can gather in living rooms, on mobile phones and behind computer screens, separated from the reality of what is happening by the comforting distance of a digital display.
That distance matters. A screen can make almost anything seem unreal. Suffering becomes an image. Violence becomes content. Death becomes something we can watch, react to and then scroll past.
The fact that millions might be able to witness an execution does not automatically make it more transparent, more just or more humane.
Transparency is important. The public should be able to scrutinise the actions of governments and the operation of their justice systems. But scrutiny does not require the public to watch a person die in real time. Independent reporting, authorised witnesses and meaningful public accountability can serve that purpose without turning the moment of death into a global spectacle.
There is also a question of dignity. A person convicted of a terrible crime does not cease to be a human being. The state may deprive that person of liberty and, where the law permits, impose the ultimate punishment. But it should not follow that every aspect of that person’s death must become a public commodity.
Human dignity cannot sensibly depend on whether we like the person whose dignity is at stake.
That principle is easy to defend when we are discussing someone innocent, someone sympathetic or someone whose life we value. It becomes considerably more difficult when the person has committed an atrocious crime. Yet it is precisely then that the principle matters most.
If our commitment to human dignity disappears whenever we encounter someone we despise, it was never much of a commitment in the first place.
I am not asking anyone to forget Hasan’s victims. Quite the opposite. Their lives should be remembered for what they were, not reduced to a grim justification for a public display of another person’s death. Nothing about questioning this proposed livestream diminishes the enormity of what happened at Fort Hood or the suffering of those affected.
Nor does it require us to settle the broader argument about capital punishment. That is a separate debate.
My concern is what we become accustomed to accepting when the state proposes that an execution should be watched by an audience.
We already live in a world in which violence can be recorded, circulated and consumed before the people involved have even been identified. The internet has given us extraordinary opportunities to share knowledge and expose wrongdoing. It has also made it possible to turn human suffering into a form of content, stripped of context and consumed at a distance.
A government should understand the difference between exposing the public to the truth and inviting the public to witness death as an event.
There is no shortage of cruelty in the world. We do not need to manufacture another spectacle to prove that cruelty exists.
And if the argument is that the condemned man must face the consequences of his actions, then let those consequences be administered according to law, with appropriate oversight and without unnecessary theatre.
Justice should not need an audience to validate it.
A government confident in its authority should not need to turn a killing into a public demonstration of power.
And a society confident in its own humanity should be capable of confronting terrible crimes without developing an appetite for watching people die.
The victims of Fort Hood deserved better than to have their lives defined by the violence that ended them. The public deserves better than to be offered an execution as a lesson in morality.
And even a man convicted of a monstrous crime remains a human being.
I am not asking us to feel sympathy for him. I am asking us to consider what it means when the deliberate taking of a human life is presented to the world as something to watch.
There is a profound difference between believing that a person must face justice and believing that the world should be invited to watch that person die.
The first is a question of law.
The second is a question of what kind of society we want to be.
And I find the prospect of confusing the two profoundly disturbing.
Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN
Dear Reader,
Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.
Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.
Donate here:
PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below
Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.
Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.
With gratitude,
The AIMN Team

Just accept the fact that humanity has changed little, if at all.
l am surprised the Trump team have missed to business opportunity that was available in traditional public executions – hawkers selling fast food ( sausage on a stick) , pickpockets taking advantage of the distraction , perhaps polaroid instant photos , for those not in the front row …USA wasting a profit opportunity by broadcasting free ? Definitely slipping here. Instant time travel back to ancient times , and it’s free!
State-sanctioned murder as entertainment. Gross. And, thus, not unexpected from the shitshow USAnia has become.
Why not set up a mini coliseum on the White House lawn, tie Hasan to a stake then let the lions loose as the cameras start to roll? And supply free champagne and cake to the cheering audience and hand out Trump/Hegseth souvenir medallions to mark the occasion. We are apparently reverting to the Dark Ages so let’s do it properly!
There is little doubt that TACO Trumpery is still trawling the depths of depravity for a spectacle to prop up his fragile ego.
State sanctioned murder is never acceptable. But how long will the victim be on death row?? In the USA (Undemocratic Sewer of Apartheid) the Kentucky woman victim of Kentucky’s failed legal system was on death row for 30 years.
In this present matter, that 30 years delay would mean that TACO Trumpery would (thankfully) be long gone to rot in his grave before the execution took place. (And common sense & decency may even have intervened, but that may be wishful thinking).
After all these years, if life sentences in prison and capital punishment (aka state murder) had the slightest influence on people commiting violent crimes… by now there wouldn’t be any!
I imagine that little Petey won’t need viagra after this travesty, he’ll be so hard he could break rocks with his little Hammer of Do(n)g.
This strikes me as being a warning that if any ‘merican steps out of line they also might find themselves in front of a firing squad.
Saddam Hussein used to have public executions and they still have them in North Korea as they do in Iran and Afghanistan: these are considered rogue regimes by many. So where does that leave Trump’s America?
The moment that Vietcong soldier was shot in the head on TV, has stayed with me forever, you could see the pain has the bullet entered his brain. And has he dropped to the ground the blood spurting from the temple. No we do not need this sort of thing livestreamed. Their is already too much of it all over the Internet.
and Trump and co sink to a new low of depravity…
When some radical muslim group take offence to it more stupid Americans will die.
In a similar vein to those above:
the Roman heirachy thought that when the plebs get restless, give them cake and bloodsports.
If the Labor-Israel-USA illegal war on Iran was to distract from the Epstein files, it seems to have worked very well. Is this now to distract from the war?
Uhm ….. does my memory serve me correctly, but wasn’t there a major MSM fuss when ISIS was beheading prisoners for public amusement??
How is this TACO Trumpery & Hogsbreath depravity any different?? Or is it again a different rule for the USA (Undemocratic Sewer of Apartheid) where rampant capitalism is insuring that eventually only one person will control all the assets in the world, just like the outcome of the Monopoly board game??
I’ll go with Jonangel this time.
Oh dear. I saw a comment on social media that if Charlie Kirk’s death was live-streamed, why is a problem with live-streaming this guy’s execution.
Spot on, NEC, yet another instance of the hypocrisy of the mainstream media. Even the criticism within the mainstream media has been tepid in comparison to the full-throated criticism (rightly so) of ISIS broadcasting beheadings.
Harks back to the days of the Roman Coliseum gross.