They’re gonna die out anyway (Part 2)

Darwin, Spencer and the “Survival of the Fittest”

Continued from Part 1

In 1859, a book was published that would profoundly influence the way Europeans thought about life, humanity and, eventually, race: Charles Darwin’s On the Origin of Species.

Darwin proposed that species were not permanently fixed, but changed over time through a process of natural selection. Organisms possessing characteristics that better enabled them to survive and reproduce were more likely to pass those characteristics to subsequent generations. Those less suited to particular environments could eventually disappear.

Darwin was describing a biological process.

Others would take his ideas somewhere Darwin himself had not intended them to go.

Even before the publication of On the Origin of Species, Herbert Spencer had been developing ideas about competition, social development and human progress. It was Spencer, rather than Darwin, who coined the phrase “survival of the fittest.”

The phrase would later become closely associated with Darwin’s theory and, more importantly for our purposes, would be applied far beyond biology.

The concept proved remarkably convenient when applied to the social order.

If competition between organisms resulted in the survival of those best adapted to their environment, some thinkers reasoned, perhaps the same principle applied to individuals, classes, nations and races.

Human societies could consequently be portrayed as participants in an evolutionary struggle in which the strongest, most intelligent or most “civilised” would inevitably prevail over those deemed inferior.

This became known as Social Darwinism.

It is important to distinguish Social Darwinism from Darwin’s own theory of natural selection. On the Origin of Species did not provide a scientific justification for racial oppression, colonial conquest or the destruction of Indigenous peoples. Darwin’s biological theories were subsequently appropriated and extended by others who sought to apply evolutionary concepts to human society.

Nevertheless, the timing was significant.

For decades before Darwin, Europeans had attempted to explain the apparent decline of Aboriginal populations in terms of divine providence or the supposed workings of nature. The extinction of Aboriginal people could be described as “the design of Providence” – an outcome ordained by forces beyond human responsibility.

Darwinian language provided another explanation.

What had previously been described as the will of Providence could now be interpreted by some as the inevitable outcome of an evolutionary struggle. The disappearance of a supposedly inferior race could be presented not as a consequence of dispossession, violence, disease and colonial expansion, but as evidence that nature itself had selected against them.

The distinction was morally convenient.

Herbert Spencer and Social Evolution

Herbert Spencer took evolutionary thinking considerably further into the social realm. He regarded the development of society and human intellect in evolutionary terms and argued that dominant races would ultimately prevail over those he considered inferior.

Spencer sought to formulate a general law of evolution and apply it not only to biological organisms but to human society itself. If evolution represented a universal process, he reasoned, then the development and transformation of societies might also be understood through evolutionary principles.

In doing so, Spencer transformed biological evolution into a social philosophy.

“Survival of the fittest” became more than a description of natural processes. It became a way of explaining – and, in some cases, defending – the social inequalities and conflicts of the nineteenth century.

Spencer himself expressed the idea in stark terms, arguing that nature’s purpose was to remove those deemed unfit, thereby clearing the way for those considered better suited to survival. He extended the concept of fitness beyond physical characteristics, arguing that nature was concerned with mental qualities as well.

This distinction was particularly important to Spencer.

He was interested not merely in physical evolution but in the evolution of the human mind. If intellectual characteristics could be inherited in the same way as physical characteristics, he believed that the intellectual capacity of a population could progressively improve across generations.

Spencer had been developing aspects of this argument well before Darwin’s Origin of Species appeared, proposing that population pressure and the struggle for survival could have a beneficial effect upon humanity. Competition, in his view, encouraged qualities such as skill, intelligence, self-control and the capacity to adapt through technological innovation. Those qualities would, in turn, promote human progress and favour the survival of the individuals best equipped to advance society.

Darwin’s work gave these ideas a new intellectual environment.

If humanity itself had evolved, it was tempting for some thinkers to conclude that different human populations might represent different stages of evolutionary development. Human “races” could consequently be placed upon an imagined evolutionary ladder, with Europeans occupying the highest position and Indigenous peoples placed somewhere below them.

This was a profound – and deeply consequential – extension of evolutionary theory.

Social Darwinism subsequently became an influential strand of conservative social thought and was used by some writers to defend racial conflict, imperial expansion and social inequality.

Darwinism was not the primary source of the aggressive racial ideologies of the late nineteenth century. Racism, imperialism and ideas of European superiority were already deeply established.

But Darwinian language provided something new.

It provided a scientific vocabulary through which existing prejudices could be presented as natural laws.

Social Darwinism Comes to Colonial Australia

Spencer’s ideas had considerable influence on European social evolutionary thinking and soon attracted an international audience. Within only a few years, his work was being discussed widely in the United States.

An 1864 article in The Atlantic Monthly described Spencer as an emerging intellectual force, suggesting that principles he had established would eventually become the recognised basis of an improved society.

Such enthusiasm illustrates the intellectual currency Spencer’s ideas had acquired beyond Britain.

Colonial Australia proved fertile ground for these theories.

Here was a new Anglo-Saxon society established on land already occupied by Indigenous peoples. Racial conflict was not an abstract philosophical problem. It was taking place in front of the colonists every day.

The destruction and displacement of Aboriginal societies therefore required an explanation.

For earlier generations of Europeans, the presumed inferiority of Aboriginal people did not necessarily explain their extinction. Social Darwinism offered a seemingly rational mechanism: if one race was supposedly more advanced, intelligent and adaptable than another, then the disappearance of the latter could be interpreted as the natural consequence of evolutionary competition.

The theory therefore offered colonial society something it badly needed – a comforting explanation for an uncomfortable reality.

The destruction of Aboriginal societies could be represented not as something Europeans had caused, but as something nature had ordained.

The colonists had not destroyed a people.

Nature had simply selected the survivors.

That interpretation was profoundly misleading. But its power lay precisely in the fact that it transformed prejudice into something that appeared to be science.

Although Darwin’s ideas were not fully accepted within Australian scientific circles until later in the nineteenth century, evolutionary concepts circulated widely in popular thought.

Social Darwinism did not create Australian racial prejudice; rather, it gave existing prejudice a new intellectual language and a new apparent legitimacy.

Europeans had already convinced themselves that Aboriginal people were inferior.

Now they had a theory that appeared to explain why the “inferior” were disappearing.

And that distinction would have enormous consequences.

Continued tomorrow: From Racial Prejudice to “Scientific” Proof

 

Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN

Dear Reader,

Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.

Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.

Donate here:

PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below

Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969

Donate Button

We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.

Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.

With gratitude,

The AIMN Team

About Michael Taylor 290 Articles
Michael is a retired Public Servant. His interests include Australian and US politics, history, travel, and Indigenous Australia. Michael holds a BA in Aboriginal Affairs Administration, a BA (Honours) in Aboriginal Studies, and a Diploma of Government.

28 Comments

  1. Assisting the confusion, the original title of Origin was On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life

    This allowed for terrible distortion, because when Darwin used the term “races” he was referring not just to variations within the human species, but all species, including plants.

    Darwin’s focus in Origin was in fact plants, and animals apart from humans, but integrity never hindered a committed racist.

    And just to add to the confusion, “Darwin’s Bulldog” Thomas Huxley, misrepresented Darwin’s work to justify class distinctions, in order to protect the interests of the British upper class.

  2. I cannot read anything with this banner ad all over the article. I dont want to unsubscribe as I know revanue is needed . But this Ad is obtrusive to the extreme.

  3. I didn’t realise they were still there, David, as I don’t see them so I assumed they had been removed. Thanks for letting me know – I’ll follow it up.

    We don’t make a cent out of those banners, btw. They are just markers of where videos or ads will be placed when they are finally approved.

  4. David, I have chased it up – they should start disappearing either late Tuesday or early Wednesday.

    You’re probably thinking what I’m thinking: “They said that a month ago.”

  5. Thanks Michael.

    I’d be interested in knowing how much the fraility of the existence for settlement contributed to the genocide.

    That is not to excuse the genocide, but how much of a factor in making the desire to dispossess the First Nations people heightened would it have been?

    If one was struggling to survive in an otherwise wilderness, then the temptation to selfishly claim land for your own use alone – an anathema to the beliefs of the First Nations people – would surely be heightened.

    Motivated reasoning does the rest, and humans are very good at coming up with or clutching rationale to justify what they feel is in their own interests.




  6. Uhm ….. Perhaps some background to ”Origin of Species”.

    The about 4 year old Charles Darwin was the very scared but unharmed survivor of runaway carriage incident, that impacted his thinking through out life. All change had to be slow, hence the claim that adaptation by natural selection only occurred slowly over many generations.

    The US Science Community were encouraged to believe this even though some suppressed US experiments showed that on some occasions natural selection could occur in one, or very few generations.

    In the other modern corner, Lysenko (USSR during 1950s) preached rapid change was possible (which suited the Communist USSR government). Obviously a difference for exploiting for political purposes by the USA.

    The 1848 discovery of Mendelian Genetics Principles in pea flowers remained hidden in an obscure German (Austrian?) science journal until about 1911 when they were re-discovered by an English scientist checking the European literature to show his work was original. Indeed, it was an independent confirmation of Mendel’s earlier work.

    Suddenly, the scientific world recognised that Mendelian Genetics provided a mechanism for natural selection. It was a simplistic solution, but none the less, demonstrated possibilities that later much research confirmed and expanded upon.

    The perversion of natural selection to describe human societies has been often referenced on AIMN by others, and is worth reading.

  7. There was a lot of it going on, Thommo. I’ve read just about every ethnography from the day – journals written by settlers – and what they recorded, oddly enough, didn’t appear in the police records.

  8. Of course Darwin’s cousin was Thomas Galton the founder of eugenics and with Bob Malthus the founder of demography and population ‘analysis’, have influence to this day…….

  9. Since colonial times “racism” (the persecution of particular ethnic communities) was not limited to aborigines. Anti-Chinese antipathy quickly developed on the gold fields and violence towards Chinese gold seekers led to the riots at Lambing Flat near present day Young, NSW. The Lambing Flat goldfields riots of 1860–1861 were among the most serious episodes of anti-Chinese violence in nineteenth-century Australia. Historic records show approximately 2,000 European diggers attacked the Chinese miners on 30 June, with about 250 Chinese seriously injured, while more than 1,000 Chinese subsequently fled the field. The riots weren’t simply a matter of miners competing for gold. The historical evidence shows a combination of economic competition, racial prejudice, rumours about further Chinese immigration, and political agitation.
    Migrants from Ireland (now Eire) did not escape the prejudices of non-Catholic colonials. Years ago I had a copy of the “Melbourne Argus” newspaper dated 1890’s. Most of the job vacancy advertisements for unskilled labourers included the acronym “NINA” – meaning no Irish need apply!! Ant-Irish racism in this instance was an expression of ethnic, political and religious intolerance.
    I often think “racism” is not the best term to use. All humans, regardless of ethnic and cultural differences are members of the human race – Homo sapiens. History shows prejudice and discrimination is about antagonism by one communal ethnic or cultural group of humans against another. Can I invent a new term – “ethnicism”?

  10. So very true, to “prejudice and discrimination”, I’d add ignorance and bigotry, “racism” doesn’t exist.

  11. Simple Thommo, “racism” only exists in the mind of racists. Which are you?
    A racist or an openent to racism?

  12. @ Thommo: Don’t bother replying to a poster whose rubbish posts are designed to annoy, rather than inform.

    Obviously jonangel supports racism, so we could reasonably conclude that he is a ”white supremacist” and possibly a self-serving Christian nationalist.

    Then analyse the simplicity of his posts and they reflect either a low personal intellect, or a juvenile primary school deliberate strategy to annoy.

  13. Michael, people across the world are victims of it and other forms of “othering”, people always seem to come with a reason, no matter how bodgy, for actually knocking off people who might challenge, or to take attention away from their own shortcomings; a place in the scheme of things, or at least being enslaved to prevent the subjugators from actually doing the hard, dirty work.

  14. NEC, I love you, you lead with your chin every time! Where have I ever supported racism? Pleas give at least one example, you, sadly are a proven dictator of exactitudes, putting it simply, you lie.
    This site provides many examples of your untruths, you really are a sorry human being.

  15. jonangel,

    you say: ‘“racism” only exists in the mind of racists’ – tell that to the Palestinians being shot as they try to harvest their olives, to those who would have voted for an Arab party in the coming election only to see them effectively banned, to those being dragged off the streets and having steel rods shoved up their rectums by Israeli guards.

    Tell that to the families of the blacks that were recently lynched in the USA.

    Tell that to the Rohingya who were genocided in Myanmar.

    “just exists in their minds” that has to be one of the most moronic things I’ve ever heard.

    The problem with people claiming ‘racism’ doesn’t exist is that it is an attempt to deny the naming of racism. If a problem can’t be named then it becomes that much more difficult to deal with. The claim that it is just ignorance and discrimination makes it that much much more difficult to deal with as that is akin to dealing with all bad things at once, rather than tackling one of the many bad things that exist in society.

    You’ve got nothin’ but bullshit and fantasies. Goodonya.

    What doesn’t exist is an “openent” anyway?

  16. Thommo, just what has the conflict in the Middle east got to do with racism? They are kissing cousins, years ag they all lived on the same land. Israel is all about land acquisition nothing more and nothing less.
    Regarding the murder of USA citizens by the fellow citizens, I’m not in a position to comment, you obviously know more than me.

    I cannot comment on the things you have “ever heard”, can I suggest you choose your friends.

    Can I conclude, by accepting you are an authority with regard to “bullshitist and fantadies”, peace be with you.

  17. jonangel,

    engage anymore than to say the following? I don’t think so.

    I got the point I wanted to make out there; you’ve served your purpose. Anything else would be giving oxygen to trolling.

  18. NEC… This site provides many examples of your untruths, you really are a sorry human being.

    That language is inappropriate.

    Come on Michael, that’s a case of sitting on the fence, isn’t it?

    I have no idea what you’re talking about.

  19. I am sorry you cannot accept the facts of life. But you will in time, you are either our your not? I’m an Australian and proud of it.

  20. Michael, I have read what you say, but am lost as to the context!! My comments relates to two different posts, if you happen to find them offensive, I’ll withdraw them, but am not sure why?

  21. @ Michael Taylor (061026 2:53PM): Uhm ….. I am a little lost. What is it that I am alleged to have said or done??

    OK ….. I have discovered the offending jonangel post. Thank you for your support Michael. Water off a duck’s back …

  22. When my dad was young ‘DYING OUT’ was accompanied with the explanation that Aust ‘Abos’ were weaker than us, so the black could be bred out.
    He used the words ‘not like African, Abos didn’t have throw backs’. I was tempted to say stronger than us but never did.
    My dad was a lovely sensitive man weakened by the war with little schooling working at a bakery from grade 3. 50 odd years ago a teacher friend, Bernie,(the grandfather, in Top End Wedding) called in and we had a beer on the verandah. Dad kept staring and looked troubled suddenly he blurted out: ‘don’t worry you were once white like us’. That is on par with the Vic who said I never saw Aboriginal people till the shiny black Africans came.
    Australians could take ‘dying out’ as already happened and Aboriginal people were invisible. Making meeting, an articulate, successful, Aboriginal teacher leaves then historically confused and unknowing about their racism.
    ps
    well done mediocrates,
    You recognize Chinese, Irish, European as deserving humans, denoting them as proper nouns and worthy of a capital letter.
    However, one set of humans (race?) is not recognised as a proper noun. Deliberate or ignorant or AI???????

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*