
Today I watched the National Press Club Luncheon, with Peter Garrett (former MP and rock legend), and Chris Barrie (former Defence chief) speaking on the report of the AUKUS Public Inquiry, which was released today.
This publicly organised, and community-funded inquiry into AUKUS has been notable for the numbers of community organisations involved in it, and for the large number of hearings, and of the people involved, and for the 1028 written submissions to it.
Equally notable is the complete lack of interest or involvement from the State or Federal governments, although they were invited. And the careful mass media also avoided it. Even today, so far, not much interest from the corporate media, but interest from many “alternative” media outlets (and the exception, the Sydney Morning Herald.) I wonder if the government, and the respectable media will be able to maintain this disdain.
But now – to the 1028 written submissions. I have ploughed through another 100 now, following my study of the first 200.
Once again, there were very few supporters of AUKUS, and these two or three writers concentrated on the argument that Australia needed the nuclear -powered submarines for security against foreign threats, especially from China.
As with the previous 200 submissions – some focussed on just the submarines themselves, others on the broader aspects of the AUKUS agreements.
Many submissions fused the two, often with the argument that the submarines would be obsolete or unsuitable for the purpose of monitoring Australia’s coastline, and that China does not pose a military threat to Australia.
And indeed, there were a remarkable number who wrote about the “non-existent China threat”, some quite passionately. An example, from Ken McCleod, Submission no. 273:
The “threat” from China rings quite hollow when China has not invaded any other country, has established no foreign bases and there is no evidence of foreign interference by China. China has never made any threats toward Australia…
China has been turned into a “threat” by a well-funded, toxic propaganda campaign,originating in the USA and meekly followed by both Australia and the UK. In fact, the USA Congress passed Bill HR 1157, which allocated $(US)1.6 billion to subsidise world media and civil society sources to produce what is basically negative, anti-China propaganda. China has no similar campaign against any other country.
If I could single out one word which pops up repeatedly in these 100 submissions, it would be the word “Sovereignty”. Consistently through so many submissions, people argued that Australia should determine its own defence needs, rather than be a tool of American militarism. An example: Submission 258. Dr Gideon Maxwell Polya says:
As a UK and thence US lackey, Australia in the last 80 years (i.e. WW2 onwards) has had armed forces in many countries of the Indo-Pacific region, and has joined the US in massive invasions and occupations…Australia should quit military links with serial war criminal, genocidally racist and egregiously mendacious America… Craven submission to American militarism makes Australia complicit in nuclear terrorism and makes Australia a prime nuclear target.
Unsurprisingly, the enormous cost to Australia of the planned submarines, and all the logistical paraphernalia surrounding them, the whole financially unfair set-up, was a very much discussed part of the writers’ gripes about AUKUS.
Many writers criticised the way in which the AUKUS agreement came about, the poor process, lack of transparency, lack of Parliamentary scrutiny, and in fact the totally undemocratic way in which the decision was first made, and then hastily agreed upon by the then Opposition Labor Party.
Strategy was another issue, with concerns on whether AUKUS is at all useful for Australia’s security. As a member of Southern and Pacific nations, AUKUS was seen as not at all helpful for regional diplomacy. An example from Submission No.300. Simon English:
Australia is a key part of Asia, so security needs to be diplomatically driven with our neighbours – eg Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia etc and utilise our trading relationship with China for strategic security. To quote the Utopia series – “we are spending billions of dollars to protect our trade routes with China from China.”
Again, the issues of nuclear wastes and their disposal, and the effect of nuclear facilities, wastes, on indigenous communities – these were mentioned often.
Many submissions were very short – but still carried their impact, especially on the question of nuclear wastes.
Some submissions were detailed, and had technical information. Most were clearly original, and from the heart. These strongly held opinions and feelings should not be ignored. Submission No 247, Antony Hing:
AUKUS is quite possibly the new “greatest moral challenge of our generation”. Australia must abandon AUKUS and make a clear statement to the world:
Nuclear war, nuclear provocation and nuclear intimidation have no place in our modern society.
Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN
Dear Reader,
Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.
Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.
Donate here:
PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below
Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.
Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.
With gratitude,
The AIMN Team

AUKUS is just another example of the politicians weapon of choice. Which is ‘fear’, fear takes the peoples mind off the poor administration and lack of quality governance being provided by our elected leaders!!
Politicians worldwide are the masters of “dived and conquer”, Japan was our enemy, now they are our friend, Russia was our ally, now they are an enemy, China is a good trading partner, but OH they cannot be trusted and round and round goes the bloody great wheel.
Australia’s subservience to USA’s foreign policy agenda originated from the Allied south west Pacific confrontation with and defeat of the Japanese Imperial Forces (JIF). To be sure Australia was vulnerable to JIF attacks having previously off-shored our meager defence forces to the UK and its European campaigns, however it should be known that USA belatedly determined that following the disaster of Pearl Harbour the entire west coast of USA was open to JIF attack. Hence Roosevelt correctly determined that the JIF must be confronted at the extremity of their supply lines in the south west Pacific and so Australia was “saved” by the outcome of the Battle of the Coral Sea. That was and is history and it all occurred 84 years ago. Australia has long since paid its debt to both USA and UK and but now must reclaim its sovereignty and diplomatically seek our peaceful destiny within our neighbouring Asian nations. Cancelling AUKUS will be a minor but necessary event in the long process of disengagement from US political and military influence in Australian affairs.
Alex Downer called AUKUS Morrison’s most substantial achievebment!!!!!
Morrison’s legacy will turn Australia into a significant power
Morrison’s legacy will turn Australia into a significant power
Instead of being loyally dependent on ‘great and powerful friends’, Australia will now share more of the burden of maintaining the balance of the power in the Indo-Pacific.
Some prime ministers were popular but we can’t remember anything lasting they achieved. Some were unpopular but have left a lasting legacy. Scott Morrison falls into the latter category. Let’s face it, at the time of the last election he was unloved by the Australian community. But this week we will be reminded of his most substantial achievement as prime minister, which is AUKUS.
Alexander Downer Mar 12, 2023
https://www.afr.com/policy/foreign-affairs/morrison-s-aukus-legacy-elevates-australia-above-also-ran-middle-power-20230309-p5cqmn
Australia’s “respectable” media (except Sydney Morning Herald) and authorities have been slow to respond to, or comment on this Public Inquiry. But America’s Politico and China’s Xinhua have covered it.
Meanwhile some very capable alternative media have commented – PS News, The Nightly, The Saturday Paper, The Point, The Pulse Illawarra.
For the Establishment, Jennifer Parker, Adjunct Professor, Defence and Security Institute, The University of Western Australia; UNSW has a go, in The Conversation. She does make some fair criticisms of the report, and she does concede some points. However, she very noticeably avoids discussing the COSTS and the nuclear WASTES, two significant areas of the report.
Noel, thanks for doing this work.
Couldn’t ever imagine going through a thousand submissions, but appreciate it when someone else does so.
@ Mediocrates, Thommo: Agreed.
@ Margot Korbell: The USUKA sub debacle had only one beneficiary – Scummo!!
A strong argument for treason could be raised against the Minister for Five Ministries, the first democratically elected dictator of Australia, as his strategy for creating his own post-politics career as a non-executive director of a US sub manufacturer profiting off the lost Australian sovereignty and $368 BILLION tribute payments for Australia to defend the USA (Undemocratic Sewer of Apartheid) all at Australian expense.