
By Eleanor Buckley
Opposition to renewable energy infrastructure has become an increasingly visible force in Australia’s energy debate.
Take Farmers Fightback, a group defending generational farmers against government overreach, with a particular focus on renewable energy. At a rally in Marnoo, Victoria, the group hosted One Nation leader Pauline Hanson, who hammered a ceremonial nail into a coffin marked “Net Zero”.
As the Coalition promises to “take a chainsaw” to Labor’s renewable energy policies, disputes over renewable energy are increasingly playing out in national politics.
But what motivates people to become so deeply involved in opposing renewable energy? And what keeps them involved?
Concerns about agricultural land, landscapes, bushfire risk and local communities are important. So too are questions about who benefits from renewable energy development and who bears the costs.
Yet these concerns alone don’t explain why people organise, protest and sustain opposition movements over many years. Our recent research suggests part of the answer lies in the social connections, shared identities and sense of purpose that develop within opposition movements.
For some participants, opposing renewable energy becomes much more than a campaign against infrastructure.
The unexpected social benefits of opposition
Research exploring the social dynamics of renewable energy opposition in Victoria’s Wimmera Mallee region found that, while people became involved for different reasons, participation in opposition movements often brought unexpected social benefits.
For farmers living in geographically dispersed communities, participating in opposition groups increased opportunities for social interaction. People described forming new friendships, attending more social events and regularly checking in on one another.
The shared experience of dealing with uncertainty and stress also opened opportunities for conversations about mental health and wellbeing, topics that can sometimes be difficult to discuss.
Public demonstrations provided a morale boost, while those taking on organising roles gained recognition and a sense of purpose. Many farmers described a moral responsibility to protect their land, communities and way of life for future generations, including standing up for neighbours who couldn’t advocate for themselves.
In other words, the opposition movement wasn’t simply a place to express dissatisfaction with renewable energy. It became a source of friendship, belonging and collective purpose.
When a shared concern becomes a shared identity
Social identity research shows that our sense of who we are is shaped partly by the groups we belong to. When people share experiences, values and grievances, they can develop a collective identity that influences how they see themselves and others.
We saw this process unfolding in the Wimmera Mallee. Farmers who initially became involved because of concerns about renewable energy infrastructure developed strong bonds through meetings, protests and shared efforts to protect their communities.
Over time, opposition became more than something they did. It became part of who they were, reinforcing their sense of purpose and responsibility to one another.
This identity was also deeply connected to place. Many farmers saw themselves as custodians of agricultural landscapes shaped by generations of farming, with a responsibility to protect them for the future.
Seen through this lens, a proposed electricity transmission line represents more than a change to the landscape. It can feel like a threat to people’s identity, autonomy and way of life.
But the same shared identity that brings people together can also deepen divisions with those outside the group.
The other side of belonging
While these social connections can bring people together, they can also deepen divisions. Our research found that a strong sense of belonging within opposition movements was often accompanied by an “us versus them” mentality. The “us” included those who shared their concerns and values, while the “them” encompassed governments, renewable energy developers and others perceived as supporting the renewable rollout.
For some farmers, this distrust extended well beyond renewable energy. Some traced their scepticism of government authority back to COVID-19 restrictions, which they viewed as government overreach and were not going to “roll over” that quickly again.
As these group identities strengthen, disagreements can become increasingly polarised. People on the other side are no longer simply seen as having different opinions, but as acting against the community’s interests. Farmers who agree to host renewable energy infrastructure, for example, can be viewed as betraying their communities. These tensions have spilled into everyday life. A Senate inquiry into climate and energy misinformation heard evidence of landowners and their families experiencing harassment, abuse and even death threats.
As these divisions deepen, they shape not only who people trust, but also which information they believe.
When trust matters more than facts
One revealing example from our research was a claim that the Victorian Government planned to cover 70% of the state’s agricultural land with renewable energy infrastructure.
More than half of the farmers we interviewed repeated some version of this claim. It has also popped up in new media platforms. It’s an extraordinary figure, and if true, it’s hardly surprising that farmers would be alarmed and motivated to oppose the rollout.
But where did it come from?
We traced it to a Victorian Government policy paper, which suggested that meeting net-zero targets using only onshore renewables could require up to 70% of agricultural land. However, the government described this as an implausible scenario, intended to demonstrate the need for offshore wind, not an actual land-use plan.
Complicating matters, the original report appeared to have been removed from the government’s website. Some farmers raised this during interviews, interpreting its disappearance as further evidence of government secrecy.
This isn’t simply a story about misinformation. The energy sector is incredibly complex, and verifying every claim requires time, expertise and access to reliable information. Instead, people often rely on sources they know and trust to make sense of it all.
When trust in government and industry is already low, information shared by peers and trusted networks can carry more weight than official evidence, even when that information is misleading. The example highlights how trust can determine what people accept as credible information, and why correcting the facts alone may do little to decrease the temperature in energy debates.
What does this mean for the energy transition?
Renewable energy disputes are about more than infrastructure. When opposition becomes intertwined with people’s identities, friendships and sense of belonging, conflicts can become harder to resolve.
For governments and developers, this reinforces the importance of meaningful community participation, recognising local values and building trust.
But understanding opposition also requires asking not only why people are fighting against infrastructure, but what they gain from fighting alongside one another. Because sometimes, what sustains a movement isn’t just the cause people are fighting for. It’s the community they’ve built in the process.
Eleanor Buckley, Crawford School of Public Policy, The Australian National University .
This article was originally published on 360info
Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN
Dear Reader,
Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.
Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.
Donate here:
PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below
Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.
Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.
With gratitude,
The AIMN Team

“But understanding opposition also requires asking not only why people are fighting against infrastructure, but what they gain from fighting alongside one another. Because sometimes, what sustains a movement isn’t just the cause people are fighting for. It’s the community they’ve built in the process.”
A very good point.
In general terms, people are rejecting the scale of infrastructure projects.
The technology exists now, for most energy needs to be provided at the community level
Give communities ownership of power production, and the resistance level will drop.
Or in this case, the ohm level will drop.
(I know, I know , not wunna me best!)
A very thoughtful comment . But how will these people feel and respond when the climate change they can no longer ignore forces them to move or seriously adapt ? Because that could be sooner than most could imagine . ln fact they are guaranteeing it will.
Central to this fossil fueled antipathy and opposition to renewables informed by Atlas Koch have been Advance types esp Lib Party head Abbott doing events in Northern Victoria (for ON?), the RW MSM and online.
However, one is appalled at the biased reporting and censorship by omission of ABC Regional and The Guardian giving the anti-renewable community groups &/or astroturfs a platform to spread BS.
Never heard farmers complain about adopting new technology and electric, but often it’s media deferring to ‘townies’, faux farmers and urban immigrants…..
With Vic election no one can explain or project how the right will prevail when right wing parties are in a civil war?
Further to my comment above about the importance of community ownership of projects.
Here’s a glimpse of the future economy by China blogger Amy Yang.
https://amyyyang00.substack.com/p/stories-of-rural-villages-in-henan
Here’s an extract.
In Europe, public squares display perfectly designed advertisements for cheap goods; here, ( Zouzhuang Village) the square is filled with people’s happy faces.
The village’s Party Secretary, Ms. Cui, introduced the local development history.
Zouzhuang Village is a resettlement village; families here were relocated because of the South-to-North Water Diversion Project.
The data speaks for itself: the village’s collective economic income has increased from 330,000 yuan to over 2 million yuan; more than 500 peasants have found employment locally, earning between 2,000 and 3,000 yuan more income every month; the cooperative pays for villagers’ medical insurance, sponsors university students, provides free water, and operates a day care center for the elderly.
While improving the living environment, the village has also established an ecological park; after being featured on CCTV’s Spring Festival Gala, “red tourism” brings approximately 80,000 tourists annually to this village.
Zouzhuang Village is both a residential community and an educational center, showcasing the principle of “common prosperity” that development must benefit everyone.
In the West, redistribution is often viewed as charity to the poor. In the Chinese context, however, common prosperity is not a gift of welfare, but the achievement of labor.
The families on the Zouzhuang Village photo wall were not saved, but were organized to lift themselves out of poverty.
The village has established cooperative enterprises which provide e-commerce training and create jobs. The fruits of collective labor return to the community through dividends and funding for public services, including ecological restoration, cultural facility construction, and other infrastructure projects that encourage people to stay in the village. In short, dignity is not bestowed from above but earned through labor.
It is possible to walk away from parasitical economic structures, but will we do it?
Or is it the case that only when we are reduced to absolute poverty by the system, when we are on the bones of our collective arse, that we will see the reality that economics is not some esoteric discipline beyond the grasp of the masses?
That economics is in fact, or should be, no more than the the exercise of mutual aid.
How could we tell this to the delusional, raving parasitical inhabitants of the destructive, murderous, intrusive USA? Trumpery is chronic cancer.
Sadly, some divisive MPs particularly LNP & PHON (for the purpose of their vested interest mates) deliberately rile up regional folk with disinformation to provoke a country/city divide. And once that ‘conspiracy’ is adopted it can become an intractable foundation.
Meantime those same MPs will be featherbedding their way into the revolving door to post-parliamentary corporate largesse.
It’s been going on for generations.
I’ll leave my comment to the links below showing the maps of energy and mining sites!
It’s not what’s going on in your small view of the world, its what’s happening outside it.
https://globalenergymonitor.org/projects/global-coal-mine-tracker
https://aenert.com/technologies/fossil-fuel/crude-oil/unconventional-oil/heavy-oil/interactive-map-of-heavy-oil-fields/