The Art of Being Brilliantly Stupid

Original image from the South China Morning Post

There is something almost impressive about Donald Trump.

Not impressive in the conventional sense. Not because he possesses some extraordinary intellectual capacity or because he has discovered a secret formula for governing.

Rather, he has demonstrated an extraordinary ability to take a criticism directed at him, turn it around, throw it at somebody else and then complain that he is the victim.

It is a political trick so simple that it can look almost stupid.

And yet, remarkably often, it works.

Psychologists have a term for one version of this behaviour: projection – attributing one’s own undesirable characteristics, feelings or behaviour to someone else.

There is another concept that is particularly useful here: DARVO – Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim and Offender. Psychologist Jennifer Freyd introduced the term in the 1990s to describe a pattern in which someone confronted with wrongdoing denies it, attacks the person making the accusation and then attempts to portray themselves as the real victim. 

It wasn’t invented to explain Donald Trump.

But watching Trump for any length of time makes you wonder whether someone slipped a copy of the manual under the door of the Oval Office.

The accusation becomes the defence

Consider the pattern.

Trump attacks Joe Biden and his family over nepotism and overseas business dealings.

Yet Trump himself placed his daughter Ivanka Trump and son-in-law Jared Kushner in senior White House advisory positions while his sons continued running the Trump Organization.

Trump calls opponents old, tired, weak or mentally diminished.

He called Hillary Clinton “Crooked Hillary” and “Low Energy” and repeatedly made age and stamina central to his attacks on “Sleep Joe” Biden.

Yet questions about Trump’s own age, stamina and verbal slips have followed him throughout his political career. As has – in his second presidency – falling asleep.

Trump repeatedly complained about rigged elections.

He described the 2020 election as stolen, despite the absence of evidence establishing the widespread fraud necessary to overturn the result. In 2026, he has continued to promote claims about fraud in the 2020 election, even though subsequent reviews of material he has presented have not substantiated those claims.

And yet, when the pressure was on after the 2020 election, Trump and his allies were the ones attempting to challenge the outcome through political, legal and electoral channels.

Trump accused others of corruption and foreign influence during the Russia investigation.

There was, in fact, extensive evidence of Russian interference in the 2016 election, and the bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee concluded that Russia sought to help Trump and damage Hillary Clinton. The committee also documented numerous contacts involving people associated with the Trump campaign.

But there is an important distinction: the committee did not conclude that the Trump campaign had colluded with the Russian government.

Trump’s response was not simply to dispute the evidence.

He turned the accusation around.

The people investigating him became the real conspirators.

The investigators became the villains.

And Trump became the victim.

And there is an intriguing twist to Trump’s obsession with the 2020 election. His persistent insistence that Democrats “rigged” that election has prompted a delicious question across social media: if Trump is so convinced that elections can be rigged, does his obsession tell us something about the way he thinks elections work? Some have even turned the accusation back on him, suggesting that his relentless claims about 2020 amount to a confession that the 2024 election was rigged in his favour. There is, of course, no evidence that the 2024 election was rigged. But as an example of projection, the irony is hard to resist.

Then there is perhaps the most obvious example of all: “Fake News.”

Trump has spent years attacking journalists and news organisations whenever their reporting is unfavourable to him.

Yet the Washington Post’s Fact Checker documented 30,573 false or misleading claims during Trump’s first presidency – an average of more than 21 a day. 

More irony that is difficult to miss.

The man who made “Fake News” one of the most recognisable political insults of the modern era generated such a volume of false and misleading claims that one major newspaper eventually had to maintain a dedicated database simply to keep track of them.

And that brings us to the really clever part.

Deny. Attack. Reverse.

DARVO has three basic components.

Deny

The allegation is false.

It never happened.

It has been exaggerated.

It is a witch hunt.

Attack

Don’t answer the question.

Attack the person asking it.

Attack the journalist.

Attack the investigator.

Attack the opponent.

Attack the institution.

Suddenly, the story isn’t about what you allegedly did.

It is about the alleged bias, corruption or dishonesty of the person asking the question.

And finally:

Reverse Victim and Offender

The person being questioned becomes the victim, the investigator becomes the persecutor, the accused becomes the persecuted, and the allegation itself becomes evidence of persecution.

Trump has repeatedly used variations of this formula.

When he faces legal proceedings, he describes them as political persecution.

When journalists challenge him, they become “Fake News.”

When investigators examine his conduct, he describes the investigation as a “witch hunt.”

When he loses an election, the election becomes “rigged” or “stolen.”

The remarkable thing isn’t that he does this: The remarkable thing is how consistently the conversation can be moved away from the original question.

And this is where the media come in

This is the part that deserves more attention.

Because DARVO – or something resembling it – can be particularly effective in a modern news environment.

A journalist may have thirty seconds to ask a question.

A politician can answer with three minutes of outrage.

The journalist asks about the allegation.

The politician attacks the journalist.

The headline becomes the politician’s attack.

The original allegation has suddenly become the second story.

And the media have another problem.

They are expected to report what politicians say.

So when a politician responds to a serious question by accusing the journalist of corruption, bias or dishonesty, the accusation itself becomes news.

The politician has effectively created a second story without answering the first.

And there is another advantage…

Exhaustion

If every allegation produces a counter-allegation, and every counter-allegation produces another controversy, eventually the public becomes tired.

What began as: “Did you do this?” becomes: “He says they did this, they say he did that, she says he is lying, he says she is corrupt…”

Eventually, people stop following the argument. And when people stop following the argument, the person who created the confusion has achieved something very useful.

The facts have disappeared into the fog.

The brilliance of the stupid

So has the thought ever entered Donald Trump’s head that we know what he is doing?

Possibly.

But there is another question worth asking: Has the thought ever entered Donald Trump’s head that he doesn’t know what he’s doing?

That may be the more interesting question, because there are two possibilities:

  1. Either Trump understands the mechanism perfectly and deliberately uses accusation, denial and counter-attack to dominate the news cycle.
  2. Or he has discovered, largely through instinct, that if he talks loudly enough, attacks quickly enough and never accepts the premise of the question, he can keep the conversation moving in whatever direction suits him.

Perhaps the answer is somewhere between the two.

And that is what makes the technique so fascinating.

It doesn’t actually require brilliance.

It requires confidence.

It requires persistence.

It requires an extraordinary willingness to never concede a point.

And, most importantly, it requires an audience and a media environment willing to follow every diversion.

Trump may not need to win every argument.

He simply needs to make sure the argument never ends.

And perhaps that is the real trick.

Not convincing everyone that he is right.

Just making it increasingly difficult for anyone to remember what the original question, claim or allegation was.

A final word

In my view, he’s too dense to notice that his projection is completely transparent. When someone keeps accusing others of rigging elections, the odds are high that they’ve done it themselves. That’s the projection I’m seeing.

 

Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN

Dear Reader,

Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.

Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.

Donate here:

PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below

Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969

Donate Button

We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.

Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.

With gratitude,

The AIMN Team

About Michael Taylor 290 Articles
Michael is a retired Public Servant. His interests include Australian and US politics, history, travel, and Indigenous Australia. Michael holds a BA in Aboriginal Affairs Administration, a BA (Honours) in Aboriginal Studies, and a Diploma of Government.

7 Comments

  1. To state that there is no evidence that the 2024 election was rigged, when you have obviously not looked at the work of Election Truth Alliance or ThisWillHold on Substack is disappointing. Your whole argument also substantiates that Trump, while he may have been upset at the 2020 result, with his claims of Democratic rigging conceals the exact same rigging that won him the 2024 election. Indeed, analysis of 20 years of election records available in Minnesota by ETA showed, using an internationally accepted method, that 2020 was also rigged in Trump’s favour. It’s just that mail-in votes were very high under Covid and eluded the grasp of their hacking. Why do you think Trump hates mail-in votes so much?

  2. Andrew, personally I believe that Trump – with the help of Musk – rigged the 2024 election. I can’t wait for all to be revealed. The issue is bubbling to the surface.

    However, until all the evidence is in and made public I’ll hold off from shouting with joy that “I knew it all along.”

  3. I’m still waiting for a journo to ask TacoTits the obvious question: if the 2016 and 2024 election results are safe, but the 2020 election was rigged, that means the only election out of the last three that was definitely corrupt was conducted under your watch, and those conducted under Democrat presidents were not (or at least not sufficiently corrupt to affect the result). How and why did you let that rigging occur?

  4. Fortunately, more Americans every day are not “buying” what perpetual confidence man master of deception Donald Trump is “selling”…

    May the clinically and criminally insane Donald Trump be mercifully removed from office before the madman gets us all killed.

  5. I agree with comments here from Andrew and Michael. There is definitely strong evidence that votes were “finagled with” in the 2024 election. The Election Truth Alliance has done many data analysis reports, and they find the same “non-human” patterns in the numbers throughout the swing states they’ve analyzed. No one has recounted or audited ballots in these areas. No one has disproved ETA’s findings. They show numbers that appear manipulated, not just in 2024, but also in 2020 and 2016. You can see this in their report called “Minnesota Then and Now” under “analyses” on their website: eta.vote
    What’s alarming is that the media and government officials are not investigating these findings, which corroborate the info from Ashley St. Clair. To dismiss all this evidence seems foolish, yet intentional. This is the U.S. now. The United States of corruption.




  6. I think Donald Trump is dense/stupid beyond compare. I find it hard to think of a single thing he has ever said or done which demonstrates leadership. He is ridiculously self absorbed and self interested. His petulant and nasty actions towards anyone he perceives as having slighted him in any way is behaviour most of us grew out of by the time we reached high school.
    But he is just the figurehead of this disastrous administration. His team of sycophants are doing the most damage and are the ones we should most fear. Not only do they enable his behaviour, they lionize it

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*