Is Australia’s social media ban a breach of children’s rights?

UNSW Sydney Media Release 

Australia’s world-first social media ban has been sold to the world as a policy to help protect children. But is it doing more harm than good?

Australia introduced the world’s first social media ban for under-16s last December. Since then, some 20 other countries have adopted similar bans, including the UK, Canada, Malaysia, Indonesia, Brazil and Austria.

The ban was pitched as a measure to protect young people’s health and wellbeing from harmful content. This includes cyberbullying, violent or sexually explicit content, scams and content that encourages unproductive or unhealthy behaviours.     

Associate Professor Noam Peleg from the School of Global & Public Law at UNSW Law & Justice agrees that there’s online content young children shouldn’t be exposed to without guide or support. But he argues the ban breaches children’s rights under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.

“Any decision or process of adopting a decision concerning children – in our case, legislation – should take the rights of children into account, including listening to children,” he says.

“In other words, you can’t form a policy about children without listening to them and then claim that it’s done for their own good.”

A right to freedom of speech

A/Prof. Peleg says limiting children’s access to social media platforms effectively prevents children under 16 from taking part in public forums, whether socially or politically.

“The ban significantly limits children’s access to information. They cannot engage with others. They cannot produce their own knowledge. They cannot be part of these knowledge production processes, which all now happen online,” he says. 

“Conversations happen online in forums, blogs and social media; you don’t send a letter to the newspaper anymore. Children have been removed from these spaces. Freedom of expression equates to the right to information and the right to assembly.”

But A/Prof. Peleg isn’t alone in raising these concerns. The Digital Freedom Project launched a High Court case against the social media ban, which is still pending.

In France last month, the Constitutional Council ruled against a social media ban for under-15s, finding that it infringed freedom of expression.

A policy designed for adults

A/Prof. Peleg also argues the ban wasn’t designed around how children engage with the online world, but around adults’ concerns about online harm.

“The outcome is an adult-centric process. It provides a so-called solution that might make sense for adults who are panicked with Instagram or TikTok,” he says.

The eSafety Commissioner’s first evaluation of the social media ban found most children aged 10 to 15 were still using social media in March as often as they were before the ban came into effect.

“The ban doesn’t correspond with the ways in which children engage with these platforms,” A/Prof. Peleg says.

Part of the problem, he argues, is that the legislation relies on categories that don’t reflect how young people engage with the online world.

Under existing measures, age restrictions apply to Facebook, Instagram, Kick, Reddit, Snapchat, TikTok, Threads, Twitch, YouTube and X (formerly Twitter). But other platforms with social or communication features, including YouTube Kids, Roblox, Messenger, Discord and WhatsApp, are excluded.

A/Prof. Peleg describes what adults define as social media as “a very 2010s term”. He adds that “for young people, the existing social media categories make no sense, especially when they’re engaging with multiple apps all at once”.

“If we don’t understand how children engage with the online world, we don’t protect children,” he says.

He points to Roblox as an example. While the gaming platform is not covered by the restrictions, some of its “worlds” can contain disturbing content, and the platform also includes communication features. eSafety has previously raised concerns about child grooming on Roblox.

The online safety regulator has also issued similar warnings about other popular gaming platforms, such as Minecraft, Fortnite and Steam, stating they “contain unlawful material or create environments for child sexual exploitation and abuse or activity which promotes, incites or instructs in matters of crime or violence”.     

Right versus wrong

But do children have the mental capacity to decide whether what they see online is right or wrong? For A/Prof. Peleg, the answer is obvious.

“When you speak to children, you realise they have the capacity to differentiate between right and wrong, between what is appropriate and what might be confronting. Any child can speak about their own experiences, and we need to listen to them, engage with their views on their own terms and provide them the knowledge and tools to engage online,” he says.

“Adults are there to broaden the conversation by considering their perspective. We need to move away from this paternalistic approach to children.”

He adds that it’s important to recognise every child’s online experience vary with age.

“The experience of a child at the age of five is different from a 13-year-old, yet this policy applies to both,” A/Prof. Peleg says.

“The discussion should be about understanding how they’re using online platforms, how they engage with the online world, and if we accept the premise that the online world can be harmful to them, we need to understand what the harm is. But we also need to remember that the online world is full of opportunities for children to play, learn and interact with peers and family members.”

Taking aim at the wrong group

Rather than take aim at users, A/Prof. Peleg says the real focus should be on holding social media and other companies, like gaming companies, accountable for allowing harmful content on their platforms. Under current legislation, social media platforms face penalties of up to $99 million if they don’t stop under-16s from creating an account.  

“We should be regulating the platforms and removing the harm. At the moment, the law doesn’t handle the source of the harm,” he says.

A/Prof. Peleg is hopeful that this will eventually happen. He compares the approach with the regulation of the tobacco and mining industries, which continue to operate, but within strict regulatory boundaries.

“People can still smoke but there are now plain packaging rules where you can’t advertise cigarettes. Or with soft drinks, people can still consume them, but they need to jump through hoops, and the nutrition value, or lack of, soft drinks appear on every can and bottle,” he says.

“We need to deal with the industry while educating the consumer. Currently, we are trying to tell the consumer you can’t do something, but it doesn’t fix the problem.”

A second chance

While children’s rights weren’t considered as part of Australia’s social media ban, there is still potential for a different approach, particularly when it comes to AI. 

The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child has announced that it will dedicate its next general comment to children’s rights and emerging technologies, including AI.

In July, UNICEF, together with France and Spain, established a Coalition for Children’s Rights and Protection in the Age of AI to ensure children’s rights, safety and wellbeing remain at the centre of AI governance. Since then, other countries including Australia, have joined. The coalition intends to present its first voluntary commitments at the Paris Peace Forum in November.

A/Prof. Peleg is cautiously optimistic of what outcomes can be delivered, saying: “Establishing this coalition is a positive step, but the question is whether it will live up to its promised mandate and deliver a framework that will cater for children’s rights and safety in a meaningful way.

“The announcement of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child is much more promising. This body of independent experts will provide, probably in 18 to 24 months, a framework to think about and regulate the online world, centering on children and their rights at the heart of this process.”

 

Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN

Dear Reader,

Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.

Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.

Donate here:

PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below

Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969

Donate Button

We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.

Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.

With gratitude,

The AIMN Team

7 Comments

  1. Who is A/Prof Peleg when he’s at home? I wonder how many shares he has in the Big Four Techs? I’ve never read such specious rubbish in all my life.

  2. Next major discussion: how age requirements for purchase and use of alcohol and nicotine are a breach of basic human rights … but first, the eternal question of how unfair it is for parents to expect teenagers to clean their own bedrooms …

    paternal approach to children
    I’m having trouble finding the right term for that particular set of words. Is it a kind of oxymoron wrapped up in a double entendre with a healthy serving of internal contradiction and cognitive bias, or just plain stupid?

  3. Handing the controllers of information for our children to the tech corporations can be seen as an abrogation of parental responsibility.

    The tech giants control the flow of information, not for the benefit of the users, but for their own profits. Adults are supposed to be responsible enough to make decisions of how they respond to on line stuff, children are not, and if we need evidence, ask any young female teacher what a mixed sexclass of year 8, 9 or 10 can be like, those young men influenced by the Tate brothers and discussions which come from the ‘manosphere’, be with a 12 year old girl who has self-harmed because of the bullying, the appearance shaming social media is full of.

    Richard Fidler’s book, Ghost Empire cites a rule from the Roman Empire, “The commandments of the laws are these: live honourably, harm no body and give everyone his due.” In giving ‘every one his due’, does that include giving parents the responsibility of parenting their children, does ‘harm nobody’ include having some guardrails which protect vulnerable people from harm, especially those deemed under the law to be too young to discern what os harmful and what is not?

    Liberalism’s struggle with th e notions of ‘freedom’ challenge that same thought, freedom is extended where it does no harm, and yet we have what is presumed to be an intelligent person, an A/Professor arguing that very ideal, arguing in effect that the harm done to children through the unfiltered algorithmic ‘news’ and the unfiltered bullying the internet has opened up is OK.

  4. @ Prof. Peleg
    “When you speak to children, you realise they have the capacity to differentiate between right and wrong, between what is appropriate and what might be confronting.”

    Yes they do have that capacity, but having worked with teens for 45 years, I can tell you without any doubt that if they get exposed to lots of crap, some can and do end up believing that it is correct, and that they can and should follow it.
    The trouble with the “tech-bro” interfaces with the world is that there are no checks and balances about what the kids are exposed to.
    Much as there may be improvements to be made, I thoroughly support what has been done so far.




  5. @ Leefe: Naughty, naughty!! Teenagers have every right to live in a self-constructed slum room. They are just preparing for their inability to afford the purchase price of a 19th century slum that will be all they can afford after they leave school to live on the totally inadequate dole rather than a Universal Basic Income (UBI).

    @ Bert Hetebry, Steve: Agreed.

  6. i can only communicate with my 12 year old daughter overseas by f/b messenger .under the rights of the child, they should be allowed to communicate with their parents but the media ban prevents this!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*